Is Ukraine finally losing the war against Moscow?

• On February 24, Vladimir Putin launched his armed troops into Ukraine for a “special military operation” which he intends to carry out in a few weeks at most.

• From the start of the war [which never said its name], the Kremlin army had to face unparalleled Ukrainian resistance.

  And she has been struggling for more than three months to claim victory.

• In recent days, the Russian air forces have intensified their operations and are trying to crack Volodymyr Zelensky's defense for good, in particular by air.

  Is Ukraine then about to give in?

  Answers with General Vincent Desportes, professor of strategy at HEC and SciencesPo, and Michel Goya, former naval officer and historian.

Three months, 96 days, 2,300 hours… It's hard to imagine that Ukraine is still resisting the Russian invader since February 24 and the launch of Moscow's “special military operation”.

It's hard to believe that a country of 45 million inhabitants has stood up, for nearly thirteen weeks, to a behemoth three times its population [and which has a military budget ten times larger].

However, this war in Ukraine is a good illustration of the story of the earthen pot facing the iron pot.

But for how long ?

In recent days the Russian noose has tightened around kyiv, more precisely around the strategic region of Donbass, and Moscow has stepped up the pace of its air attacks.

“After three months of conflict, one thing is clear: the balance of power is indeed almost balanced,” says General Vincent Desportes, author of

(Ed. Denoël).

For this former army soldier, “in terms of combat neither of the two countries” is however “superior enough to the other to achieve real breakthroughs”.

The war in Ukraine would then have become a "nibbling war" during which everyone fights back, small victory after small victory, without being able to claim victory.

“Vladimir Putin underestimated all the layers of this conflict”

Without forgetting that “Vladimir Putin underestimated all the layers of this conflict”, still accuses General Vincent Desportes.

First, the Ukrainian people whom he took for “little Russians”, then Volodymyr Zelensky whom he saw as a “clown” then Europe, which he thought was “a bunch of soft nations”.

And "despising your enemy is surely one of the worst strategic mistakes in wartime", concludes the man who is also a professor of strategy at HEC and SciencesPo.

This is why Russia quickly found itself in difficulty, had to face unparalleled Ukrainian resistance and has struggled for more than three months to claim victory.

Seeing his strategy slipping, Putin therefore changed his tune.

Its objective, after taking the port city of Mariupol, became that of conquering the whole of Donbass.

Russian troops are surely advancing there and pounding the towns of this region located in the east of Ukraine.

But probably not fast enough.

This is surely the reason why for several days Vladimir Putin's armed forces have been trying to break through directly from the sky, multiplying air attacks.

The battle in the air, the key to Russian victory?

According to Michel Goya, however, it is not in the air that Moscow's victory over kyiv will be found.

“One of the great surprises of this war is precisely the weakness of the Russian air force,” says the former officer in the army's marine troops.

The Kremlin fleet would indeed be less modern and efficient than that envisaged by the international community or anticipated by the Ukrainian forces.

“The Russians have lost a lot of planes since the beginning of the conflict and are forced, to avoid breakage, to fly very low, which makes their attacks much less effective”, further specifies Michel Goya.

On the other hand, it was these planes that allowed the Russians to take possession of the town of Popasna located east of the Donbass and, according to the former soldier, this is perhaps where the Russians will meet victory: “ this city is placed on the heights and offers a strategic vision of all the regions of eastern Ukraine, so coveted by Vladimir Putin.

Thanks to this positioning, the Russian army would then be able to encircle a city like Severodonetsk, “one of the last pockets of resistance in the Donbass, sheltering a sixth of the Ukrainian army”, according to the historian.

"And if controlling the Donbass means winning the war then it is possible to envisage a victory for the Russians by the end of the summer", he concludes.

#Ukraine: The Ukrainian 80th Air Assault Brigade hit an attempted Russian (VDV) push in the vicinity of #Popasna with artillery- as a result, three BMP-3 IFVs were destroyed.

pic.twitter.com/kfEHmMTDjh

— 🇺🇦 Ukraine Weapons Tracker (@UAWeapons) May 30, 2022

Access to this content has been blocked to respect your choice of consent

By clicking on "

", you accept the deposit of cookies by external services and will thus have access to the content of our partners

I ACCEPT

And to better remunerate 20 Minutes, do not hesitate to accept all cookies, even for one day only, via our "I accept for today" button in the banner below.

More information on the Cookie Management Policy page.

On Tuesday, the governor of the Lugansk region announced that Russian forces now controlled "part" of Severodonetsk, which they had been shelling for weeks.

“The situation is ultra-complicated”, indicated on Telegram Serguiï Gaïdaï.

the governor, however, clarified that the Russians "could not advance freely", with Ukrainian fighters "still remaining" in the city.

A war in Ukraine made up of "attacks and retreats"

"A war ends either by total destruction or by negotiations", cowards for his part Vincent Desportes.

The professor of strategy at Sciences Po and HEC thus joins Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky who affirmed at the end of March, during an interview granted to Ukrainian television, that the war would not end on the "field of battle but on that of negotiations".

Only, in the game of negotiations, everyone must find his account.

“At this stage, Vladimir Putin has not gained enough territory to be able to justify a conflict of such magnitude.

For his part, Volodymyr Zelensky must regain ground to have material for compromise, ”says Vincent Desportes.

If the two countries know that it takes mutual consent rather than joint destruction, negotiating does not necessarily mean an end to the fighting.

“As a reminder, during the 1973 negotiations between the United States and Vietnam, the Americans bombed Hanoi more than reason,” recalls the general.

In the end, this war in Ukraine is made up of “attacks and setbacks” which make any prediction difficult… but which thumb their noses at the theory of the strongest.

World

War in Ukraine: Annexation in progress for Russia and destruction well in place for Ukraine

War in Ukraine: The Russian army claims to have destroyed a Ukrainian arsenal in Dnipropetrovsk

• World

• War in Ukraine

• Donbass

• Volodymyr Zelensky

• Vladimir Poutine

• Russia