"We must aim for a collective sobriety that encourages small gestures"

• It is difficult today to ignore the scale of the energy crisis we are facing and which could worsen further in the months to come, leading to supply cuts.

• Since this summer, the government has been preparing the French for the prospect of a harsh winter, with appeals to sobriety launched to individuals and businesses alike.

  A sobriety roadmap is also in preparation and should be presented soon.

• How can we reduce our consumption beyond small daily gestures, which are useful but insufficient?

  This is the challenge of the ongoing reflection for the think-tank Terra Nova, which puts fourteen proposals on the table.

  Nicolas Goldberg, energy manager of the think-tank, tells us more.

Sobriety… The term has never been referred to as much as this fall.

Starting with the executive.

On July 14, Emmanuel Macron mentioned a “sobriety plan” being prepared, which Elisabeth Borne should present at the end of September or the beginning of October.

Amazing to see how this concept, once reviled when invoked to reduce our greenhouse gas emissions, has become fashionable in a few months.

The war in Ukraine and the prospect of having to do without Russian hydrocarbons have passed by, aggravating the energy crisis that was simmering in Europe and exposing it to a high-risk winter.

With "high prices for sure, restrictions no doubt, supply cuts perhaps", portrays Terra Nova.

In this context, “sobriety will be necessary to reduce our energy consumption and collectively face the shock that we are already undergoing”, continues the think-tank.

It remains to embark all the French in this process of sobriety.

With this in mind, Terra Nova submits fourteen measures for debate in a note published on August 23.

The author, Nicolas Goldberg, “energy” manager of the think-tank, responds to

.

Access to this content has been blocked to respect your choice of consent

By clicking on "

", you accept the deposit of cookies by external services and will thus have access to the content of our partners

I ACCEPT

And to better remunerate 20 Minutes, do not hesitate to accept all cookies, even for one day only, via our "I accept for today" button in the banner below.

More information on the Cookie Management Policy page.

What is the genesis of this note?

Is it precisely this announcement of an upcoming sobriety plan, by Emmanuel Macron, on July 14?

No, we started to work on this note in June, when we began to have the first injunctions for “small gestures”.

It's good, these small gestures.

They have an effect.

But sobriety doesn't stop there.

We wanted to think about ways to stimulate a collective sobriety that does not denigrate these small gestures but encourages them, while having a scale effect.

In the meantime, there has been the announcement of a sobriety plan.

Of course, our fourteen proposals can provide food for thought, we were also consulted by the government.

We just hope that we will not retain only the short-term measures aimed at securing energy supplies this winter.

Our latest proposals are much more about long-term changes.

We must consider this energy crisis as an opportunity to put us collectively on the path to more active and faster decarbonization.

On June 23, Elisabeth Borne and Agnès Pannier-Runacher set the objective of reducing France's final energy consumption by 10% within ten years... Why this course, which may seem easy at first glance, is far of being ?

By way of comparison, the first Energy-Climate package of the European Council, in 2008, set a target of 20% final energy savings in twenty years.

It was not reached by France.

Aiming for -10% in two years means going five times faster.

Sectors have already taken care to reduce their consumption, quite simply because it impacted their competitiveness.

This is the case with industry.

Furthermore, we have already captured the easiest sources of savings.

In particular the gradual transition from incandescent lighting to fluorescence lighting (LED).

Another example: the installation of doors on fridges in hypermarkets.

In 2012, the sector committed to closing 75% of its fridges by 2020. This effort has led to a significant drop in electricity consumption in the sector.

Fortunately, there are still many levers to pull.

In the building sector in particular.

Are we still in France in a relationship to energy as if it were abundant?

Yes, but because we are not yet feeling this energy crisis.

The tariff shield [which, since October, freezes the price of gas and limits the rise in the price of electricity to 4%] has annihilated any price signal which should encourage us, individuals and professionals, to save energy and invest of efficiency.

Without it, our electricity bills would have increased by 35%.

We are well aware at Terra Nova that many households are already struggling to pay their energy bills and could not afford such increases.

There are still smarter measures to take than this tariff shield without social targeting and very financially heavy for the State [20.7 billion euros at the last count in July].

We propose to turn it off gradually,

In parallel, it is necessary to revive and generalize the tariffs created during the oil crisis of 1973 by EDF then in monopoly.

In particular the differentiated rates per hour, the famous peak hours / off-peak hours.

But also so-called “mobile peak” tariffs such as the EJP or Tempo.

They make it possible to benefit from an advantageous price per kwh most of the year, in return for a very high price on certain days [22 for the EPJ] in periods of very high demand.

Customers are notified the day before.

These tariffs have been completely abandoned

This contributes to one of the strong issues that you highlight in your note: give the right indications to the French so that they adapt their behavior?

It is one of the levers on which to work.

It is far from negligible.

We saw this recently with the Ecowatt system, which both individuals and professionals can sign up for.

They receive alerts from RTE when there is a risk for electricity supplies, with invitations to eco-gestures.

In April, the Ecowatt orange alert broadcast nationally by RTE saved 800 megawatts (MW) at peak consumption.

It's a lot.

And this device is still quite confidential.

Imagine if it is massive.

In the same vein, we are proposing to add an “energy weather forecast” to daily bulletins, particularly on television.

It would give daily forecasts of the voltages on the electrical network, often linked to temperatures, with indications on the behavior to adopt.

Before this work on the right indicators, you recommend starting by applying existing laws.

In particular on the ban on heated terraces, on the lighting of commercial signs at night... The most obvious and the easiest in the end?

The easiest, not necessarily, because it implies a desire to implement them, the means to carry out checks on the ground.

But yes, many sobriety measures are already enshrined in law and are not being followed.

A recent example is that of heated terraces, normally prohibited since March 31 by the Climate and Resilience law.

This measure was followed very little in the cold periods that followed in April, in the name of a “temporary tolerance”.

This is just one example.

The extinction of illuminated signs at night is neither monitored nor controlled.

There are also all those energy code measures that limit the upper heating (19°C) and cooling temperatures for air conditioning (26°C) in buildings.

If it turns out to be complex and intrusive to apply this type of regulation in private housing, the State and local authorities should at least apply these measures, which do not require any investment, to all of their buildings. .

In any case, there are significant energy savings to be made by enforcing these laws.

And that's not the only issue.

If all public buildings limit heating to 19°C, then private individuals will be tempted to do so.

If you give the French the necessary infrastructure and you show them the example, then the eco-gestures, they do them.

We insist on the State's duty to set an example.

We could even go so far as to turn off the public lighting of monuments on days of tension.

It's symbolic, of course, but it would send the right signal.

And in the long term, what should be done?

We must maintain the effort on the measures already identified, for a large part, in the objectives of reducing our carbon footprint.

Everything related to sustainable mobility plans (reviving rail, limiting air transport, developing soft mobility, legislating on the weight of vehicles, etc.), changes in consumption patterns (less disposables, more short circuits, etc.) , land use planning (bringing living and shopping areas closer to workplaces, etc.).

We could have devoted a separate note to these subjects.

For a large part, the answer will lie in the redesign of the commons rather than in energy solutions, often fossil fuels.

This implies making sobriety a desirable long-term social project.

Policy

Energy sobriety: Elisabeth Borne calls on companies to act to avoid “rationing”

Planet

War in Ukraine: "In France, we don't have oil, but we have ideas"... How the conflict takes us back to the oil shock of 1973

• Planet

• energy

• energy savings

• War in Ukraine

• electricity

• Gas