Great report

Massacre of October 17, 1961: 60 years of struggle for the recognition of a State crime

Audio 7:30 p.m.

Algerian demonstrators arrested in Puteaux, west of Paris, during the peaceful demonstration, October 17, 1961. 60 years ago, 30,000 Algerians who came to demonstrate peacefully in Paris suffered violent repression.

Official report: three dead and sixty wounded, very far from reality according to historians.

© AFP/Fernand Parizot

By: Marie Casadebaig Follow

13 mins

On October 17, 1961, the repression of a peaceful demonstration by Algerians in the heart of Paris caused the death of 200 to 300 people, killed by the police.

Sixty years later, associations are still fighting for the French State to recognize its responsibility.

(Replay)

Advertising

The Pont de Neuilly district has changed a lot in 60 years.

The trees have disappeared and given way to the office buildings of La Défense.

The bridge that spans the Seine and connects the western suburbs to Paris has become a very busy artery.

This Tuesday evening, October 17, 1961, it is precisely this bridge that the Benaissa family is preparing to cross to respond to the call to demonstrate from the French federation of the National Liberation Front (FLN). 

The Algerian independence movement has called for a march towards the heart of Paris to denounce the curfew imposed for a few days on the " 

French Muslims of Algeria

 ", as they are then called, and to demand peace.

Like hundreds of other Algerians, Khaled Benaissa, 13 years old at the time, his father, his brothers, his uncles left the shantytown of Nanterre.

They will never be able to cross the Seine.

“ 

The mobile guard had completely closed the passage of the bridge.

Some had machine guns with a tripod on the ground.

This is the memory I have when all the first rows fell as a result of the bullets already fired.

There was certainly an order that no Algerian pass.

I tried to run to hide… It was dark night.

And there I stumbled.

I thought it was the sidewalk, but it was bodies.

And other bodies fell on me,

says

Khaled.

I couldn't free myself anymore.

I was starting to lose my breath.

I gasped and thought my time had come.

I started to say my prayers and miraculously someone pulled me by my feet from the pile of dead bodies and wounded men who couldn't move.

He was my uncle.

»

“I had never seen that in my life”

That same evening, just on the other side of the Seine, Catherine Levy, 19, returns home after an evening at the cinema with friends.

Without understanding it right away, this philosophy student becomes the witness of a premeditated and organized police repression which strikes in several places of the capital.

“ 

When I arrived at the Neuilly bridge, I was completely flabbergasted.

On the platform, there were people, obviously Algerians, who were bloodied and the cops forbade anyone to speak to them.

I understood when I went out because I met a friend who also had a pad nearby.

Like me, he had seen people bleeding.

I had never seen that in my life.

As soon as they saw Algerians, the cops beat on them

.

»

At the Renault factory in Boulogne-Billancourt where they work, Clara and Henri Benoit, 31 and 35, rub shoulders with many Algerians employed on the assembly lines.

His trade union commitment plunges the couple into history in motion.

“ 

The Renault FLN came to find us saying: '

We are going to organize a demonstration.

We contest our representativeness of the people and since relations with the police are what they are, I ask you to come and write everything you can see,” recalls Henri Benoît.

“ 

They had instructions to go there unarmed.

There were four or five of us at Renault and we had been told to go to Opéra

 ,” adds Clara.

“ 

There were several police vans, ”

continues Benoît.

As people whose profile suggested they were Algerians came out of the metro, they were checked.

In the meantime, a growing mass of Algerians has built up.

We followed the demonstration on the sidewalk, which was, as far as I remember, silent.

Until the moment when we arrived at the height of the Rex, the cinema.

And that's when we heard gunshots, the dispersal. 

»

 And there, it was the stampede.

We saw that the demonstration spread out into all the surrounding streets to escape the barrage of fire from the police.

And then we found a comrade from Renault who was in the car and we went around,

continues Clara.

There, we saw the police vans picking up, so to speak, Algerians.

I have the memory in the metro of having seen, from a little far indeed, bodies spread out.

 »

underestimated victims

The police are overwhelmed by the mobilization.

Municipal buses are requisitioned to pick up as many Algerians as possible and take them to improvised places of detention.

Some demonstrators spend several days there, deprived of food, beaten, humiliated... The official report mentions two Algerian deaths.

“ 

This assessment was perpetuated as a false official truth by the prefect of police Maurice Papon, who published his memoirs in the 1980s

, explains historian Gilles Manceron, specialist in the colonial history of France

.

In reality, Jean-Luc Einaudi, the main author of books on this event, from the 1990s, tried to make lists of missing persons.

He arrives at a first quantified assessment which revolves around 200 victims who disappeared on October 17, in the weeks preceding and immediately following 

.

To the 200 dead in Paris, we must surely add a hundred on the other side of the Mediterranean.

Deportations to Algeria are not a simple return to the country.

These men are parked in military camps.

Some die there.

In the days that followed, the press relayed the official message or fell foul of censorship.

Violence gives way to silence and absence, in the Renault factory in Boulogne-Billancourt as in the shanty town of Nanterre.

" 

It's still quite distressing to find mothers whose husbands have been arrested and who turn to the works council because it was a welcoming place to find out what to do, how to have news.

These are

things you can't forget

 ,” confides Henri Benoît.

There are CGT leaflets that were published the next day or two days later because in some workshops, Algerian workers were absent

 ," says his wife Clara.

An outburst of violence that remains an "enigma"

“ 

I think the information has circulated.

There were those who didn't fit and the bodies that people had seen floating in the water.

The idea is that many Algerians have been thrown into the water.

In the shantytown, some have returned and others never.

Life took over.

Me, I went back to school,

says Khaled Benaissa.

People spoke very little about it because children also had to be protected, I think.

 »

This outburst of violence remains an “enigma”.

We are a few months away from the Evian agreements.

Nothing stands in the way of the independence of Algeria.

But Prime Minister Michel Debré, whose position on Algeria diverges from that of President De Gaulle, is dispossessed of the file.

He still keeps his hand on maintaining order.

The prefect of the Seine at the time armed auxiliaries.

Death squads sow terror within the Algerian community from the end of the summer of 1961. October 17 is a high point.

But it will take 20 years for the truth to begin to emerge.

“ 

There has been a tendency in France on the part of the official authorities to put a modest veil on this event as on the violence of the war,

notes the historian Gilles Manceron

.

Georges Pompidou went further than de Gaulle.

It was necessary, he once said, “

to erase the periods when the French did not like each other

”.

Giscard d'Estaing went much further because he was rather pro-French Algeria at the time 

”.

 "

 It was not until the 1980s, although Mitterrand was not too keen on telling the truth about this period when his attitude was not always very clear, for there to be a beginning of the process of establishing the facts , including on October 17,

continues the historian.

A process that also relies on the families of Algerians who have suffered this repression and who are beginning to speak.

Some families have told their children and these children are beginning to demonstrate at the Saint-Denis canal, for example, where there were drowned victims, at the Saint-Michel bridge, and certain associations are joining in.

At the end of the 1980s, the association

Au nom de la mémoire was formed

, with children of immigration.

 »

To perpetuate the memory and the fight

These children of immigration have grown up well.

They themselves became parents, grandparents, but their fight has not changed.

The issue is transmission

,” said one of them.

And me, when I talk to my children every day, I tell them one very important thing: it's not a memory of pathos.

We are not here to cry, to say “

here we are, we are the victims

”.

Not at all.

We are proud that our parents, our grandparents, carried this story and that they remained standing.

What must be valued is courage

, ”he insists.

As every year, as October 17 approaches, associations of survivors, children of victims and supporters meet to organize commemorations of the massacre, in Paris and in the suburbs.

To the duty to remember their first years of struggle, concrete demands were added 20 years ago: recognition of the responsibility of the French State, access to archives and a place of memory.

But the recognition of the French state is only progressing slowly.

“ 

We could almost repeat the 2001 call word for word. This proves the extraordinary resistance we are encountering to obtain recognition of what was perpetrated 60 years ago 

,” laments Olivier Le Cour Grandmaison, political scientist, academic and member of the unitary collective October 17, 1961, for the recognition of a state crime.

In Clichy-La-Garenne in 2011, François Hollande, then presidential candidate, paid tribute to the victims of October 17, 1961 to "

simply remember what happened, that is to say several dozen died in tragic conditions

.

“A year later, in 2012, the socialist president is the first head of state to recognize “

a bloody repression on October 17, 1961

” in a press release.

A derisory gesture for Olivier Le Cour Grandmaison.

If the Republic were so lucid, it could not qualify the massacres of October 17, 1961 as bloody repression.

October 17 must be considered a massacre, with summary executions, drownings... We know that there were in the very courtyard of the police headquarters, a few tens of meters from the offices of Maurice Papon, summary executions.

»

The political class united in denial

North-west of Paris, in Colombes, the small square in front of the Simone Veil elementary school will become the forecourt of 17-October-1961 from this Sunday.

We are part of this memory of the Paris region.

It is therefore a plaque which will indicate that we inaugurated a square on October 17, 1961. There may also be a description of the events as we have in other neighboring towns,

"says Alexis Bachelay, deputy mayor of the city.

However, the installation of this simple plate was not without difficulty.

Before the town hall of Colombe swung to the left in 2020, Alexis Bachelay was a municipal councilor in the opposition.

"

For 15 years, despite repeated requests, despite the presence of associations, of families whose parents, brothers, sisters were victims of the repression of October 17, the municipality stubbornly refused to grant a place of memory,

remembers the chosen one.

We had somewhat surprising exchanges in the municipal council.

He said to himself that these were brawls between FLN militants and that in these brawls, there had actually been deaths.

It really went as far as a form of historical revisionism and denial of the gravity of the repression, of the gravity of the event.

Given that these were people who claimed to be politically Gaullist, there was also this idea that we were going to tarnish not only the image of France, but also the image of their political family and of what they believed as activists

.

»

Alexis Bachelay takes advantage of a mandate as a deputy between 2012 and 2017 to try, with others, to pass a bill for the recognition of the responsibility of the French State in the massacre of October 17.

He will not even obtain the support of his political group, socialist, ecologist and republican.

"

In the case of the Algerian war, and perhaps even more of October 17, 1961 because it happened in Paris, the whole thing undermines the national republican mythology on the idea that the Republic has always faithful to its principles,

analyzes political scientist

Olivier Le Cour Grandmaison

.

This challenges partisan mythologies, those of the Communist Party leadership, which has always claimed to have been consistently anti-colonialist.

In the case of Algeria, this is not true.

This calls into question that of the Socialist Party as the great party of emancipation and progress, whose ancestor, the SFIO, played an absolutely deleterious role during the Algerian war.

And it undermines great personal mythologies.

Who was prime minister?

Michel Debré, one of the writers of the Constitution of the Fifth Republic.

Who was President of the Republic at the time?

General de Gaulle.

All of these elements mean that, on the right as for part of the governmental left, this past is an extremely dangerous past.

»

After the words of candidate Macron on the barbarism of colonization and the gesture of the Head of State towards the harkis, very recently, the associations hope that the 60th anniversary of the massacre will mark a turning point.

"

I'm not necessarily unbridled optimism because it seems to me that Emmanuel Macron is adopting a tactic which consists of giving in a little so as not to give in on the substance, "

says

Olivier Le Cour Grandmaison

.

If we compare with most of the other great European colonial powers, or most of the other States which were built on the partial destruction of the indigenous populations, we realize to what extent, indeed, in these areas and on these matters , France is ominously late.

While tensions are high with Algiers, October 17 could be one of those occasions for calming down on the memorial subjects that Emmanuel Macron wants.

Whatever happens, Sunday and like every year, the associations will be there on the Saint-Michel bridge, in the heart of Paris.

Because here, 60 years ago, the Algerians were drowned.

Newsletter

Receive all the international news directly in your mailbox

I subscribe

Follow all the international news by downloading the RFI application

google-play-badge_EN

  • Africa

  • France

  • Algeria

  • our selection

  • Story

On the same subject

France / Algeria

Anniversary of October 17, 1961: moving from knowledge to recognition

France

The recognition by François Hollande of the massacre of October 17, 1961 is debated

The Media Workshop

1 - The demonstration of October 17, 1961