French press review

In the spotlight: the repatriation of jihadist mothers and their children

Audio 04:06

Émilie König - whose photo was taken in the Roj camp in northeastern Syria in March 2021 - is one of 16 women repatriated to France.

© AFP/Delil Souleiman

By: Frédéric Couteau Follow

4 mins

Advertising

“ 

Until the end, the initiative remained secret,

points out

Le Parisien.

Yesterday

[July 5, Editor's note],

the Quai d'Orsay announced that it had repatriated 51 people held in Kurdish camps in northeastern Syria.

It is the most massive operation ever carried out since the fall of the Islamic State in 2019. But the main novelty,

notes the newspaper,

is that, for the first time, France has decided to repatriate adults from the camps.

Of the 51 people who landed at Vélizy-Villacoublay airport yesterday, 16 are women.

The other 35 are minors, including 7 unaccompanied children.

This decision is akin to a political turning point, France has so far applied the case-by-case doctrine for minors and refused to return mothers.

The situation of all these jihadist women, aged 22 to 39, was judicialized,

notes

Le Parisien again.

Eight of them were the subject of an arrest warrant.

Seven were immediately brought before an investigating judge and placed in protective custody.

 »

Preserving what makes us human

The daily

La Croix

welcomes this repatriation: “

 For democracies, the fight against terrorism does not only consist in saving lives, but in trying to preserve what makes us human.

In this regard, respect for human rights is not an option, let alone an admission of weakness.

It is in this sense that the announcement of repatriation should be welcomed.

(…)

In this case, there has been much debate about the long-term risks,

further notes

The cross.

In fact, among the women repatriated yesterday, at least one is considered an active member of Daesh.

She will be judged.

We also know how complex the reintegration of children confronted with atrocities and potentially indoctrinated is.

They will be accompanied.

These reservations, apparently legitimate, do not hold for whoever chooses to place the principle of humanity above the precautionary principle.

This involves accepting some risk.

The part that distinguishes civilized societies from the totalitarian logic of terrorism 

”.

Facing your own failure

A necessary repatriation 

", adds

Les Dernieres Nouvelles d'Alsace.

 While Belgium, Denmark, the Netherlands or Germany decided to repatriate all of their nationals, France stuck to a

“case by case” policy,

to the point of being singled out by human rights organizations.

Marking a break (therefore), this first massive repatriation comes after the electoral deadlines and the trial of the attacks of November 13, also before a possible condemnation by the European Court of Human Rights 

”.

Admittedly, the Alsatian daily points out, “ 

justice must be rendered and the State must provide the means to the security services to guarantee the monitoring of these soldiers of Allah.

But this repatriation also forces the country to face up to its own failure, that of having abandoned part of its youth to merchants of hate.

Extracting child victims of jihad from the Syrian camps is a first step in restoring the dignity of the Republic

 ”.

Will the Borne government be able to break the distrust of the French?

Also on the front page, the baptism of fire in front of the deputies for Elisabeth Borne this Wednesday, July 6.

“ 

Serious things are beginning,

exclaims

Liberation.

Emmanuel Macron met yesterday with a restricted government council to discuss the fight for purchasing power, a highly anticipated subject which will be at the heart of Prime Minister Elisabeth Borne's general policy speech this Wednesday.

 »

L'Opinion

wonders: " 

failing to solicit the confidence of the deputies, will Elisabeth Borne manage to break the distrust of the French?

If the purchasing power law has test value, it is primarily on the ability of the Prime Minister to respond to the number one concern of the population, with consistency and efficiency. 

»

More broadly, will this government be able to meet the expectations of the French?

Le Monde

hardly believes in it, describing the new team as "

 plethoric and breathless

 ": " 

focused on the known allies of Emmanuel Macron, this government seems to lack vision at the dawn of a legislature which promises to be complicated ,

says the evening daily.

(…)

Withdrawn into its square backyard, too isolated to dare to demand a vote of confidence from the National Assembly, the new team now has only one word in its mouth,

"action"

, to try to contain the very political game of oppositions.

Rarely, under the Fifth Republic, has a government appeared so disarmed at the dawn of a new legislature

 ”.

Newsletter

Receive all the international news directly in your mailbox

I subscribe

Follow all the international news by downloading the RFI application

google-play-badge_EN

  • Newspaper

  • French politics

  • Elisabeth Borne

  • France

  • Terrorism

  • Justice