Children glued to screens, to the point of threatening their development.

The idea regularly worries many personalities and politicians who call for it to be a public health issue.

However, the scientific data are far from supporting such alarmism.

"The overexposure of children to screens could be the evil of the century", estimated in December a hundred French deputies in a column published in

Le Monde

.

These elected officials belong to the presidential majority of Emmanuel Macron but their text was also signed by opponents from both right and left, such as the former socialist presidential candidate Benoît Hamon, as well as personalities such as the singer of the group Indochine, Nicola Sirkis.

Effects on sleep, emotion management, language acquisition

This vast panel testifies to the widespread repercussions of a concern: children spend too much time in front of screens - computers, smartphones, televisions, etc. - and this endangers their good intellectual development.

Regularly expressed for years in a context of the rise of new technologies, this fear has found a new echo with the Covid-19 crisis.

The closure of schools and confinements have particularly exposed children to screens, whether in a school or recreational setting.

However, screens have "a harmful influence on sleep, food or even the management of emotions", they also threaten "the acquisition of language (and) the memorization of knowledge", hammered the signatories of the forum, who submitted a bill to the Assembly at the end of February to carry out awareness-raising actions.

A “weak” link between screens and behavioral problems

However, these concerns are far from unanimous among psychiatrists and child development specialists.

Studies on the subject are numerous, but their conclusions vary greatly and their quality is very uneven.

In children under twelve, there is indeed a link between time spent in front of screens and possible behavioral problems, but this is "weak", shows a study published this week in JAMA Psychiatry, the one of the leading psychiatric research journals.

This study is important because it is not an isolated work among others.

This is a "meta-analysis", which includes a large number of pre-existing studies and assesses in particular their level of seriousness.

Its conclusions are therefore, a priori, much more solid than these studies taken separately.

However, it is precisely the least serious studies that tend to be the most alarmist.

According to the authors, these works frequently tend to “exaggerate the effects (of screens) because of a lack of methodological rigor”.

A symptom rather than a cause

The authors also note that the most recent studies, on the whole, show less and less of a marked link between exposure to screens and behavioral problems.

Admittedly, this study admits that there is a relationship between the two phenomena but “the links found are really light, which is reassuring”, commented the British psychiatrist Russell Viner, who did not participate in this work.

Above all, it is very difficult to say in which direction the relationship of cause and effect is going.

Are children having problems because they have looked at screens too much... or are they spending too much time in front of them because they already have problems, for example related to difficulties in their home or a lack of social life ?

By targeting screens, we risk attacking the symptom rather than the cause.

“This is a very complex subject and we cannot conclude that it is the exposure to screens which creates problems”, estimated Russell Viner, in a comment addressed to the organization Science Media Center.

“For many children, as for us adults, (…) screens can be a positive source of education and distraction,” he concluded.

Health

Covid-19: More than half of children have increased their screen consumption since the health crisis

Society

Safer Internet Day: Parental control, advice site… How to help parents better protect their children from the dangers of screens

  • Health

  • Television

  • Child

  • smartphone

  • Tablet

  • 0 comment

  • 0 share

    • Share on Messenger

    • Share on Facebook

    • Share on Twitter

    • Share on Flipboard

    • Share on Pinterest

    • Share on Linkedin

    • Send by Mail

  • To safeguard

  • A fault ?

  • To print