A few years ago, the number of

caesarean sections

performed in Spain and whether they were many, few or normal could be approached from a strictly medical point of view.

With data, with the National Institute of Statistics (INE), with the World Health Organization (WHO)...

Now the concept of

"obstetric violence"

has been incorporated into the debate and, suddenly, the approach to this issue has become sharper and more dangerous.

Obstetricians deny the majority, since it involves accepting an intention to cause harm that they reject, while some women's groups consider it a reality that sometimes deprives them of deciding about their own body.

Be that as it may, the first thing, the numbers.

According to the INE, in 2020 (latest available data), 341,315 creatures were born in Spain.

75% were by natural or vaginal delivery and 25% by

cesarean section

.

These figures, 'grossly mode', have remained in that proportion for years and exceed the recommendations of the WHO, which considers the ideal rate of caesarean sections between

10% and 15%.

If we look at Europe and the OECD, Spain is in the middle of both tables, between figures that exceed 50% of

cesarean

deliveries (Cyprus, Turkey and

Mexico

) and those of those countries that do not reach 20% (in descending order: France, Estonia, Lithuania, Denmark, Finland, Sweden, Iceland, Norway, the Netherlands and

Israel

).

Eurostat

OECD

the judicialization of obstetrics

Dr. Juan Luis Delgado is president of the Perinatal Medicine Section of SEGO, the Spanish Society of Gynecology and Obstetrics.

In his opinion, the reasons for a cesarean section cannot be attributed to medical factors alone.

"Society is changing: on the one hand,

pregnant

women are making more and more decisions and on the other, we are experiencing an increase in lawsuits because there is less tolerance for adversity. People look to blame when things don't end as expected", he says.

Delgado explains that in a context of late and highly calculated motherhood, pregnancy has become highly idealized and is surrounded by a procession that hides a reality: both pregnancy and childbirth, even though they are physiological processes, can lead to dangerous situations for the baby. and for the mother.

So much so, he explains, that they are the cause of many hospital emergencies.

"We obstetricians are under a lot of pressure. On the one hand, because of the accusations we receive of obstetric violence and, on the other, because of the judicialization of our specialty. This has led to an

increase in defensive medicine

," says the doctor.

He not only points out to professionals that "to avoid problems if something goes wrong they have to do more cesarean sections", but there are women who demand them because they feel safer than before a vaginal birth.

Is childbirth so dangerous?

And here comes the story.

Andrea Ros is the creator of the Madremente support community for mothers and a perinatal promoter.

In his opinion, the narrative surrounding pregnancy and, above all, childbirth, is dominated by violence, terror, pain... "A natural process, suddenly, has become dangerous and, without medical causes that they advise it,

cesarean sections

are considered as

one more option to be born

. And let's not forget that it is a major surgery, "he warns.

She complains that women are often not informed of the risks involved in an intervention like this and for her, in a natural childbirth

without complications

, there are too many gynecologists and not enough midwives: "Obstetricians have little training in the physiology of childbirth, because They study pathologies, yes, but they can arrive at a delivery room without ever having seen one," he says.

In line with the French obstetrician Michel Odent, he complains about the medicalization of childbirth, its excessive protocols, inductions, etc., since he considers them a direct path to dehumanization.

"When a baby is born, the

highest peak of oxytocin

that we will ever have is produced and we bond with the baby. In a caesarean section this does not happen. If we continue like this, what will become of humanity? We are at a time to ask ourselves questions" says Andrea Ross.

One of the practices he opposes is the trend of offering an

induction

to a pregnant woman in her 40th week of pregnancy.

Many of these inductions end in caesarean sections, as labor does not begin naturally.

"The average for gilts is 41 weeks plus one day (41+1), so what's the rush?"

Ros admits that after 40 the baby's risk of death multiplies by two.

"There are two deaths out of every thousand. If you only say 'double', the woman gets scared. Let's tell her that the risk goes up, but that she can control herself. Let's not infantilize them," she emphasizes.

And he settles: "If there is a risk, we also want a caesarean section. We are not unbalanced

or crazy hippies

."

schedule deliveries

Shutterstock

Dr. Juan Luis Delgado explains that in Spain, the cesarean rate in private centers is around 45% and in public ones, which have audits that examine the numbers, it is around 11% in low complexity hospitals, and 18%- 20%, in those who receive the highest risk cases.

"To lower these figures, we have to

reduce induction

for convenience and assume that delivery times are long," he defends.

The doctor explains that two-thirds of

caesarean sections

are performed for three reasons:

  • The baby is

    breech

    .

    A report known as the 'Hannah Study' (The Lancet, 2000), later criticized, instituted caesarean section in these cases to the point that, although a maneuver can attempt to turn the fetus around, caesarean sections with babies of buttocks in women who already have more children have multiplied by 12 since then.

  • Labor

    induction

    .

    In induced first-time mothers, caesarean sections have multiplied by seven.

    The advantages of advancing a delivery can be to reduce the risk of fetal death, hemorrhage and reduce the excessive weight of the baby, among others.

    But there are also paramedical causes and this is where the melon of childbirth by convenience

    opens

    .

    "Births can be scheduled to adjust the agendas of doctors, of couples who live at a distance, to better manage hospital pressure, to attend to the wishes of the mother and even to want a capicua date for the birth," acknowledges the doctor. .

  • Having a

    previous cesarean section

    .

    "In these cases, the scar can break during childbirth and that creates fear for women and gynecologists as well, since it is a cause for legal action," she explains.

    However, if more than 18 months have passed since that C-section, there is less risk of

    uterine rupture

    , she says.

  • Are vaginal births possible after two caesarean sections?

    And right here, another melon opens: that of vaginal deliveries after one or two previous caesarean sections.

    Nuria Martínez, coordinator of the El Parto es Nuestro association in Valladolid, tells Yo Dona about her life experience, in an almost obsessive quest to give birth naturally.

    "We only defend being treated according to

    scientific evidence

    and always respecting the woman's decision," she claims.

    Nuria has four children (16, 14, 10 and 8 years old), the first two born by

    caesarean section

    and the last two by vaginal delivery.

    To achieve this, she had to fight

    against all odds

    , that is, against the doctors: "In fact, in my city I couldn't because there is no public hospital in all of Castilla y León that would allow me to try it after two caesarean sections," she explains. .

    Her determination, after a first caesarean section with many complications and a second one that she did not want and that caused her deep post-traumatic stress, led her to do

    "obstetric tourism"

    , as they call it in El Parto es Nuestro.

    She gave birth to her third child without complications at the Hospital de Cruces, in Bilbao, and her fourth, at the Hospital de Torrejón, in Madrid.

    "We only ask that they let us make our decisions about our body," she concludes.

    Conforms to The Trust Project criteria

    Know more

    • Maternity

    LifestyleIsabel II or Nicole Kidman, the mothers who have publicly disowned a child

    ParentingHow to get your children to collaborate at home

    BeautyThese are the 10 keys to achieving perfect eyebrows

    See links of interest

    • Last News

    • Work calendar 2022

    • Home THE WORLD today

    • How to do

    • Apothecary Garcia

    • Cadiz - Celta Vigo

    • Villarreal - Real Madrid

    • Rayo Vallecano - Osasuna

    • Atletico Madrid - Getafe

    • Alaves - Valencia CF

    Keywords: