Impact Report 2020 Tesla's electric vehicles, more efficient than those of its rivals
More than two decades ago, the independent vehicle safety tests, EuroNCAP, were born to evaluate with objective tests the active and passive safety of each model on the market.
The notes congratulate or scold the manufacturers
in order to further protect passengers and avoid serious injuries and deaths.
In the midst of a climate emergency, a twin institute that measures automotive toxicity has emerged:
GrenNCAP
.
The credibility of the tests, both safety and environmental, must be held in an
independence from the manufacturers of which there is no doubt
.
In this sense, GreenNCAP makes sure to
test vehicles with 2,000 or 3,000 kilometers driven
, most of them coming from car rental companies.
In no case, they assure, are they provided by the manufacturers.
One of the tests to which the Toyota Yaris Hybrid was subjected by GreenNCAP
Comprehensive measurements
The measurements are quite complex, but they address a crucial aspect: the difference between the official homologation granted to new vehicles and the actual figures for consumption, efficiency and greenhouse gas emissions during the actual circulation of the vehicle.
GreenNCAP declares its intention to reward manufacturers that go beyond the regulations required by the authorities of the European Union.
Thus, with a mixture of measurements in cold, on highways or in the conditions of maximum temperature, between the road and the laboratory the vehicles are evaluated.
As in EuroNCAP, this ecological evaluation body simplifies the results with the star system, in the style of the rating of hotels.
Five stars is the maximum.
There are also half stars to highlight nuances within a similar performance of the mechanics.
Only one tenth in the efficiency section separates the Nissan Leaf from the full.
Three parameters
The specific notes are divided into three aspects:
emissions of particles into the air, energy efficiency and greenhouse gas emissions
.
Every year we try to improve the analysis including small improvements that can change the note of the same model in 2020 and in 2021.
The star rating for plug-in hybrids (PHEV) takes into account polluting emissions, energy efficiency and greenhouse gases in two driving modes: mainly using the combustion engine and when the battery is the main source of energy.
The electrics
No car powered by fossil fuels reaches five stars
, an exclusive preserve of electric vehicles, among which there are few things that separate them, since
all of them achieve the highest rating in the sections of emissions, both for particles and CO2.
. The difference then lies in the almost negligible nuances obtained in the laboratory when using the car when it is cold or when it is already running or in cold or hot outdoor conditions.
The 'energy efficiency' parameter is the amount of energy it takes to move the car. Here less is more, better grade
.
The only one that achieves a 10 in the three plots
of those analyzed in 2021 is the
Fiat 500 e,
the urban one with an 87 kW electric motor and a 42.0 kWh battery.
The lower the weight, the greater the efficiency
, but the advantage in this section between some battery-powered cars is
only a few tenths
.
By size and performance, the Lexus UX 300e is the most developed 'five-star' electric.
Lexus UX 300e, leader in power
Only one tenth separates the
Nissan Leaf e +
from the Italian utility.
Its 9.9 in efficiency makes it a 100% ecological car according to GreenNCAP.
The tenth for 10 comes from a higher expense in the test in a cold environment (32 kWh / 100km).
Taking into account its greater weight and higher performance, the
Lexus UX 300e Automatic would be the true leader of the table
, with the 'ten' in emissions and a 9.7 in energy efficiency, where it also falls due to its higher cost in cold environments .
The electric
Volkswagen ID.3 Pro
and
Ford Mustang Mach e
complete the list of the 'five stars' with this engine.
There is one more, but with hydrogen-based combustion: the
Hyundai Nexo
, with a considerably lower score (7.3) in the energy efficiency section.
In the
2020
tests
, only the
Hyundai Kona Electric
and
Renault Zoe
achieved all stars.
The Toyota Prius PHEV is the only car that has achieved four stars in GreenNCAP tests.
Only one with four stars
Going back to this year, the latest tests have found only one car worthy of GreenNCAP's remarkable high or four stars: the
Toyota Prius Plug In
4x2 CVT.
This plug-in hybrid or PHEV achieves an excellent 8.3 in energy efficiency and combines this note with a 6 in 'clean air' or particle emission and with a 7 in greenhouse emissions.
A very respectful diesel
Few come close to the plug-in Prius
.
We now review those that have been rated with
three and a half stars
, among which we find a family car with diesel engine: the
Skoda Octavia Combi 4x2 with manual transmission
.
"The car scores highly in all three evaluation areas: 6.7 / 10 for Clean Air, 7.7 / 10 for Energy Efficiency and 4.6 / 10 for Greenhouse Gases," concludes the examiner.
The Skoda
demonstrates how a job on the TDI engine can reach heights better than the electrified ones
.
It is the best of those rated with three and a half stars in the efficiency section
.
Exceptional result of the Skoda Octavia Combi TDI: a diesel as environmentally friendly as many PHEVs.
Another car with thermal motorization, in this case of gasoline, that has achieved the notable is the
Volkswagen Golf TSI 1.5
with manual gearbox.
It achieves practically the same rating as its plug-in hybrid brother, the
GTE 180 KW Plug-in Hybrid 4X2
which emits more greenhouse gases.
A rating very similar to that of the VW Golf is obtained by another car with a gasoline engine, the
Mazda2 Skyactiv-G
with manual
transmission
and front wheel drive.
PHEV territory
The
Renault Captur, Honda Jazz and Kia Niro
also get three and a half stars
, all with plug-in hybrid technology.
A non-plug-in hybrid, the Toyota Yaris
with a 1.5-liter gasoline engine, has found its place among the elite of cars considered greener than those analyzed by GreenNCAP in 2021.
For more information on analyzed models and measurement systems, you can consult the
GreenNCAP
page
According to the criteria of The Trust Project
Know more
Skoda
European Union
Hybrid cars
Motor
MotorFord S-Max and Galaxy: hybrid air in seven seats to resurrect the minivan
MotorThe Government parks, for now, the change in the labels of the DGT
MotorToyota bZ4x: an electric whose batteries are 'eternal'
See links of interest
The Palm
Last News
What
2022 business calendar
Christmas Lottery 2021
Search Christmas lottery number
Covid passport
Holidays 2021
Loteria del Niño 2022
Internazionale - Napoli
Huesca - Ibiza
Tenerife - Alcorcón
Elche - Real Betis
Inherit San Pablo Burgos - Barça