Jia Pingwa’s daughter’s poems can be criticized, but don’t presume your position based on your status
■ Observer
The attack on Jia Qianqian is not a poetic criticism or commentary, but a typical network communication.
On many occasions, Jia Pingwa has said that he does not encourage his daughter Jia Qian to write poems.
He hoped that she could be an ordinary person, "The literary world has high mountains and rivers, the wind and rain, people are too tired to live, and I do not like to hear the second generation of Wen said that such a hat is easy to wear, it is ugly, and My head hurts."
It now appears that its intuition is surprisingly "accurate."
In the past few days, Jia Qianqian’s poems have received a lot of criticism, coupled with the identity tag of "Jia Pingwa's Daughter", there is more room for interpretation.
In January last year, Jia Qianqian’s collection of poems "The Inland Lake in the Coconut" was published, but it became popular in the past two days. Netizens seem to have found some help in it, and took the opportunity to attack it.
Qingqing shouted/My sister is shit on my bed/Waiting for us to run/Lang Lang is already calmly/Pinch a piece of shit/Get off the bed/Like a returning king-"Lang Lang"
In fact, this poem is about the daily life of your little daughter. If you are a parent, you will definitely not feel nauseous and nauseous when you see such a scene, but will only feel funny.
People use words like "poop" and "baba" to describe children's excrement, which in itself is "poetic."
At the end of this poem, there is actually a mockery of chicken soup words like "The Returning King".
Poetry is indefinite, and modern poetry is even more amorphous.
But many people ridiculed the "shallow and shallow style", believing that such influential words were written into poetry and tarnished the purity of poetry and Chinese.
In fact, many of Jia Qianqian's poems "Inland Lake in the Coconut" are serious poems, not as "shallow" as netizens tease.
For example, this song--
Some of the seawater is tied in the coconut / becomes a quiet inland lake / it refuses to participate in the tie-dye of time / like the object in the ancient text / you can only stand with your hands down / look up to it-"Coconut"
As a language art, poetry has a major mission to be exploratory and to attract people's thinking.
The content expression and text selection do not avoid the "down-to-earth" aspect, which is also the characteristic of many modern poems.
To a certain extent, the attack on Jia Qianqian is not a poetic criticism or comment, but a typical network communication, in a common saying, it is "with rhythm."
Another reason for questioning Jia Qianqian's poems is his identity.
This is Jia Pingwa's previous worries.
While many netizens mocked Jia Qianqian, they also took the opportunity to mock Jia Pingwa.
According to reports, as early as 2001, Jia Pingwa served as a tutor for postgraduates at Northwestern University; more than ten years later, Jia Qianqian taught in a related college and published papers on his father. These connections would hardly not arouse public opinion.
For Jia Qianqian, this is something she must endure, and for the reasonable doubts, she may need to come out and give more explanations.
It is not impossible to play as "Jia Pingwa's Daughter", but it cannot be without boundaries.
Many netizens now question Jia Qianqian based on the imaginary "inside theories".
But extracting poem fragments and criticizing it is difficult to provide support for the brain supplement conclusion based on the position first, and it is more like black and black.
Yes, there can be many subjective evaluation criteria for poetry.
But in any case, the evaluation standard should be "on poetry based on poetry"-at least, the poetry standard should be used to evaluate poetry itself.
That kind of out-of-context evaluation is really "shallow".
□Zhang Feng (media person)