The mystery of the death after the guard room of Shandong Teachers College was beaten: three times to identify two causes of death

Surging News Reporter Chen Leizhu

In the four years after the death of Yu Qinheng, a middle school physics teacher in Mingcun Town Center, Pingdu City, Shandong Province, his cause of death was once a mystery haunting his family. This all stems from a fight on February 28, 2016.

Yu Qinheng ’s sister Yu Weijie told Peng Mei News (www.thepaper.cn) that on the day of the incident, a family member of a teacher named Liu had a dispute with a guard Chen Mou. He died at the age of 47, only 47 years old.

After Yu Qinheng's death, public security organs issued two "Appraisal Opinion Notices" successively, describing the causes of Qin Heng's death as "conflict of limbs, emotional excitement, drunkenness, etc., leading to extensive bleeding of the subarachnoid space and sudden sudden death of heart disease "And" Extensive subretinal hemorrhage, intracranial hemorrhage caused death; there is a causal relationship between drinking and mood changes and the consequences of death. "

Accordingly, the Pingdu Public Security Bureau decided to withdraw the case on January 16, 2017. After that, the case entered a civil trial, but during the trial period, upon the commission of the court, the original appraisal agency issued a supplementary appraisal opinion saying that Yu Qinheng ’s death "was between this trauma event, drinking, emotional changes, and untimely treatment. There is a certain cause and effect. "

According to this supplementary appraisal, Yu Qinheng's family applied to the public security organ for a new case on December 24, 2018 after withdrawing the complaint. However, more than a year later, no reply was received from the public security organ.

On April 7, the Pingdu City Public Security Bureau responded to Pengpao News that after communication and argumentation, combined with the investigation, the three appraisal opinions did not contradict each other, and Yu Qinheng ’s death was a non-traumatic death, which was not in line with the reopening of the case. condition.

Yu Weijie mentioned his brother's death with sadness. Surging News Reporter Chen Leizhutu Murder Case in Guard House

Yu Weijie still remembers that on the day his brother Yu Qinheng died, his friends and students came to hundreds of people one after another. She said that Yu Qinheng is a kind-hearted and an excellent teacher. "His honor certificates can be more than one meter tall." On May 22, 2016, many people came to express their condolences to Qinheng spontaneously, which made Yu Weijie and his parents both moved and sad.

Yu Weijie is still constantly imagining that if it were n’t for the sudden “accident”, their home in Mingcun Town would still be a well-off family that many people admire, but with the death of Yu Qinheng, this family was in four years Has been in trouble several times.

According to the memories of Yu Qinheng's family, on February 28, 2016, shortly after the Spring Festival, Yu Qinheng received a call from a school colleague, and then a few people went to a restaurant in the town to have dinner. Yu Weijie said that when his brother left home, he never came back. After receiving the news of his death, the family learned that, when Yu Qinheng passed the school after dinner in the afternoon, he saw someone in the guard room arguing, and was persuaded in the process of persuasion. Be killed.

According to an insider, at the beginning of 2016, when Mingcun Town Central Middle School was relocating, after the Spring Festival, the school's teaching building and office building had been moved to the new campus, and only the teachers' dormitory had not been moved. The old campus was in After the ground facilities are demolished, they will be used to build residential buildings. At that time, the developer has sent some demolition personnel and guards to the school. "One afternoon before the incident, the mother-in-law of a teacher named Liu in the school was picked up by the old campus. The guard hired by the developer seized the tricycle. At noon the next day, when the teacher's wife went to the guard room to talk with the guard, the two sides clashed. "

The above-mentioned insider said that Yu Qinheng had dinner with the above-mentioned teacher and wife couple Liu and several other teachers at noon that day. When several people returned to the staff dormitory after dinner, the wife of teacher Liu surname went in when they passed the guard house. Theory with her guards about her mother picking up wooden blocks, hoping not to stop them in the future. After the quarrel between the two, Yu Qinheng and other talents entered the guard room to persuade them, and then several passing teachers rushed in to squeeze the small guard room.

During the squabbling, the two sides shoved. The guard Chen suddenly picked up a thermos and hit the head of a Li staff in the school. The guard room was in a mess for a time, and several people helped the injured out.

"The conflict had escalated at the time." The insider said that after Chen Mou wounded people with a hot water bottle, the wife of the aforementioned teacher Liu surnamed immediately tore with Chen Mou. After she was slipped by the water on the ground, Chen Mou will She pressed on the ground, and Yu Qinheng saw Chen Mou strangling his neck from behind (note: it is said to hug his shoulders). When Chen Mou broke free, Qinheng hit his head for a while, Then Yu Qinheng collapsed on the bed in the guard room.

Yu Weijie said that when Yu Qinheng was sent to the hospital, he had no vital signs. When the family arrived at the hospital on the afternoon of that day, the doctor had rescued Qinheng for more than half an hour, but he was not able to save him.

The guard house that happened that year was retained after the school was demolished. Surging news reporter Chen Leizhu identified suspect cloud

After a lapse of four years, the building of the old campus of Mingcun Town Central Middle School has been demolished. A new residential building has been built here. The guard room where the life was originally committed has been retained, but it has been abandoned.

When the nearby merchants and residents mentioned the death of Qinheng in the past, they all said they knew it, but they did not want to talk about the incident. Even the teacher Liu, the employee Li, and others who had experienced it in the previous article When several witness teachers mentioned this matter, they also chose to avoid it on the grounds of "inconvenience" and "no comment". Surging News then collected several transcripts of the enquiries made by the public security organs after the incident, which showed that the incident was basically the same as what the insider said.

In the descriptions of these in-persons, many people said that after Yu Qinheng fell, several teachers on the scene had to carry Yu Qinheng to the hospital, but they were stopped by Chen. They would wait for the police at the police station to let them take them. Yu Qinheng went to the hospital. Chen also confirmed this detail. In the interrogation transcript, he said that he was worried that Yu Qinheng and others would rely on him, so he proposed to wait for someone at the police station to come and take a look.

Yu Qinheng was not effectively treated by a doctor. Two months after his death, the Pingdu Public Security Bureau issued a Notice of Appraisal Opinion on April 29, 2016, saying that the deceased Yu Qinheng was in conformity with physical conflict, emotional excitement, Factors such as drunkenness induce subarachnoid hemorrhage, heart attack and sudden death.

For this result, Yu Weijie and her parents could not accept it. She said that her brother had no history of heart disease during his lifetime, and he never found any health problems during the school ’s annual physical examination. They subsequently proposed a re-appraisal. The Pingdu Public Security Bureau Mingcun Police Station entrusted Beijing Zhongzheng Judicial Appraisal Institute to conduct an appraisal, and issued a "Appraisal Opinion Notice" on October 27, 2016, which showed that Yu Qinheng was in line with a wide range of Cavity hemorrhage and intracranial hemorrhage cause death; there is a certain causal relationship between drinking and mood changes and the consequences of death.

Strangely, the second “Judicial Appraisal Opinion” and “Appraisal Opinion Notice” obtained by Peng Mei News show that the acceptance date and appraisal date of this appraisal by Beijing Zhongzheng Forensic Laboratory are both November 2016 On the 3rd, the Public Security Bureau of Pingdu City issued the "Appraisal Opinion Notice" to the family members on October 27, and the appraisal conclusions of the two documents were completely consistent.

Peng Mei News consulted two judicial appraisal reports and found that the Criminal Science and Technology Office of Pingdu Public Security Bureau pointed out in its "Forensic Examination Certificate of Forensic Medicine" that Yu Qinheng had diffuse subarachnoid hemorrhage in the brain and suffered from hypertension. Heart disease, according to the case, is considered to be in accordance with factors such as physical conflict, emotional excitement, and drunkenness, which lead to subarachnoid hemorrhage and sudden death due to heart disease attack.

According to the "Appraisal Opinion" of Beijing Zhongzheng Forensic Laboratory, according to the biopsy of heart disease, Yu Qinheng's death due to heart disease can be excluded. The appraisal opinion of the institute excluded the cause of the "sudden death of heart disease", and put forward the opinion of "death caused by intracranial hemorrhage" for the first time.

Yu Qin's pre-photo. Family prosecution and withdrawal

Both of the aforementioned identifications indicated that Yu Qinheng had subarachnoid hemorrhage, pons and intramedullary hemorrhage, but neither of them had a clear relationship with trauma. He believed that Yu Qinheng's death was related to his own drinking and mood changes. The Pingdu City Public Security Bureau issued the "Decision of Cancellation Case" on January 16, 2017, saying that it was found that the criminal suspect Chen Mou should not be investigated for criminal responsibility during the investigation and decided to withdraw the case.

After the case was dismissed, Yu Qinheng's family still doubted the result of his death "caused by his own reasons", and he was not convinced that "Chen should not be held criminally responsible".

Yu Weijie said that after that, they applied to the Pingdu People's Procuratorate for filing supervision, and the court issued a "Notice of Review Opinions on Reasons for Not Filing" on March 30, 2017, saying that the Pingdu City Public Security Bureau had explained to the court that it was not filed. The reason, the court found after examination that the Pingdu Public Security Bureau's reasons for not filing the case were established.

Yu Weijie said that the notice of review opinion completely ended the death of his brother at the criminal level, but the parents were still unwilling. After half a year, he repeatedly reported the matter to the petition department.

On November 8, 2017, the Pingdu Bureau of Letters and Calls and Yu Qinheng ’s father Yu Wenqing signed the “Supplement of Interests and Recalls Agreement”, which showed that due to the incapacity of the couple and their family life, the city ’s letters and visits The bureau pays 250,000 yuan from the special fund for letters and visits to resolve the letter and visit matters at one time.

Yu Weijie said that the 250,000 yuan was more like a “relief fund”, and it was given to the elderly who had a difficult life after losing their son. The two elderly people were very moved at the time. “The case was nowhere to go at the criminal level. We have already decided to accept the reality, and we want to wait until the civil lawsuit is over, and forget about it.

On January 10, 2018, Yu Qinheng ’s parents filed a total of 11 people with Chen Mou and related personnel who participated in the incident on the day of the incident to the People ’s Court of Pingdu City, demanding compensation for death compensation, funeral expenses, transportation expenses, and spiritual comfort money. A total of 1376392.5 yuan.

During the hearing of the case, the court held that the original evidence was unclear and applied to the original appraisal agency Beijing Zhongzheng Judicial Laboratory for a supplementary appraisal of the causal relationship between Qinheng ’s death and his trauma.

On November 7, 2018, the Beijing Zhongzheng Forensic Laboratory issued a "Supplementary Opinion on Forensic Expertise", which showed that Yu Qinheng felt unwell after torn with others in the guard room of the original Mingcun Middle School in Pingdu City and sent it to Pingdu City. The village hospital found dead.

Beijing Zhongzheng Judicial Laboratory analyzed and believed that before the death of Qin Heng, there was a torture incident with the person, and the head was subjected to external forces; and after Qin Heng fell to the ground, he was blocked from seeing a doctor. Based on this, the Institute obtained the final supplementary appraisal opinion that Yu Qinheng ’s death has a certain causal relationship with the trauma event, alcohol consumption, mood changes and untimely treatment.

It is precisely because of the supplementary description of "trauma incident" and "external force" in this supplementary appraisal that made the case confusing again and again, and finally led to the withdrawal of Yu Qinheng's family.

The cause of Yu Qinheng ’s death described in the notice of appraisal opinion issued by the Pingdu Public Security Bureau for the first time was related to sudden death caused by a heart attack, but this claim was erased in the subsequent appraisal. Surging news reporter Chen Leizhutu

The Pingdu Public Security Bureau withdrew the case on January 16, 2017. Surging news reporter Chen Leizhutu "non-traumatic death"

In the nearly three years after Qin Heng ’s death, after three judicial appraisals, from sudden death of heart disease to intracranial hemorrhage, he finally pointed out that there was a certain causal relationship with the traumatic event, and it was clear that Chen ’s obstruction of medical treatment also led to the death of Yu Qinheng. One of the reasons.

Yu Weijie said that she and her family believed that the supplementary appraisal opinion could explain that Yu Qinheng ’s death was caused by Chen ’s human factors. After consultation, the family decided to withdraw the case and apply to the public security organ for a new case.

On December 24, 2018, Yu Qinheng ’s family submitted the "Judicial Appraisal Supplementary Opinion" issued by Beijing Zhongzheng Judicial Appraisal together with the application for filing to Pingdu Public Security Bureau. They believe that this new evidence can prove that Qin Heng ’s death was related to Chen ’s trauma and obstruction of medical treatment. He requested the Pingdu Public Security Bureau to file an investigation and take coercive measures against Chen according to law.

Yu Weijie thought that after the application was filed, the case would soon be reversed, but today, the case has not been reopened. Her parents were also flattened on August 23, 2019 due to "noisy visits" The Municipal Public Security Bureau took it from his home and was later detained in criminal detention on suspicion of provoking trouble. Now he has been apprehended by the procuratorate.

In this case of lethality, why is there a big difference between the opinions of the three judicial appraisals? Why is the second "Appraisal Opinion Notice" issued earlier than the appraisal time? Can the new evidence support the reopening of the case?

The Pingdu Public Security Bureau responded to the surging news on April 7 that the identification of the cause of death was professional. After in-depth communication between the Bureau and the judicial appraisal agency, an expert was also hired to conduct an argument that the three appraisal opinions were not in conflict with each other. It is considered that Yu Qinheng is non-traumatic.

In its reply, Pingdu Public Security Bureau stated that the time before the second "Appraisal Opinion Notice" was issued before the appraisal time was caused by the case handling personnel's improper operation of the case handling system and did not affect the effectiveness of the appraisal; the bureau combined communication and argumentation The investigation concluded that the decision to cancel the case was clear and well-founded, and did not meet the conditions for reopening the case.

Regarding these three appraisal opinions, a forensic expert who has been engaged in forensic pathology and clinical examination and appraisal work for nearly 30 years has analyzed Peng Mei News that the appraisal opinions made by the Criminal Science and Technology Office of the Pingdu Public Security Bureau are in agreement with the Beijing Zhongzheng Forensic Laboratory. The two appraisal opinions were not consistent. Although the causes of death in the three appraisal mentioned "subarachnoid hemorrhage", there was a contradiction between "sudden cardiac death" and "intracranial hemorrhage".

The above experts said that from the analysis of appraisal opinions, drinking, mood changes and untimely treatment are all factors in the "trauma event", and "trauma death" are two concepts, and there are many factors that cause intracranial hemorrhage, so "trauma" There is a certain causal relationship between events and death "to a certain extent, it can be concluded that" non-traumatic lethal ". However, in the three appraisals, it was clearly pointed out that Yu Qinheng had "intramedullary hemorrhage". "The results of this test are related to trauma. I think the statement of" non-traumatic lethal "is not rigorous."

Yu Weijie said that his brother had been dead for four years. The cause of his death had changed in multiple identifications and replies. Now the application for reopening the case was rejected. She was at a loss, "I have no spare time now, I just want to wait for my parents to be safe Come back home".