Will there be a reprieve for eternal pollutants? The deputies will examine on Thursday April 4 a bill aimed at restricting the manufacture and sale of products containing PFAS, the adoption of which is uncertain in the face of reservations from the presidential camp, under pressure from manufacturers.

Massively present in everyday life (Teflon pans, food packaging, textiles, automobiles, etc.), these per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances called PFAS (pronounced "pifasse") owe their nickname to their very long life cycle and, for some , to their harmful effect on health.

At first glance consensual, the bill presented by ecologist Nicolas Thierry, first of eight texts presented by his group as part of its parliamentary niche, should ultimately be hotly debated.

See also Eternal pollutants: towards a total ban on these persistent chemical molecules?

The government highlighted the work underway at European level on Wednesday. “It is at the European level that we must fight on this subject, the European lever is the right lever” in order not to weaken French industry at the expense of those of neighboring countries, declared in the hemicycle the Prime Minister, Gabriel Attal.

The European Chemicals Agency published a draft ban in 2023 moving in the direction of a broad restriction of PFAS. But "this initiative is conditional on a long decision-making process and could result in the most favorable scenario by 2027-2028", according to Nicolas Thierry.

Eternal pollutants: per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) © Jonathan Walter, Sabrina Blanchard, AFP

Restricted ambition

The text from the MP for Gironde aims to reduce the population's exposure to these molecules, by prohibiting the manufacture, import, export and marketing of certain products which contain them.

In its initial version, it planned to ban the use of PFAS by July 2025 for certain products, and 2027 for others, with possible exemptions. In order to obtain a majority in the Sustainable Development Committee last week, Nicolas Thierry agreed to restrict its ambition.

The version presented in the hemicycle thus provides for a ban from January 1, 2026 on any kitchen utensil, cosmetic product, wax product (for skis) or textile clothing product containing per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, The exception of protective clothing for security and civil safety professionals.

All textiles would be affected by the ban from January 1, 2030. The packaging sector, however, falls outside the scope of the law, to the extent that a European regulation must “very soon” regulate it more strictly.

Demonstration of Seb group employees against a bill aiming to ban per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in France from 2026, on April 3, 2024 in Paris. © Alain Jocard, AFP

Other measures include the obligation to control the presence of PFAS in drinking water throughout the country and the application of the polluter pays principle with a tax targeting manufacturers who release them.

Also readDrinking water in danger: pesticides, new eternal pollutants?

“Don’t touch my frying pan”

Despite this rewriting, the text continues to arouse reluctance.

Author of a report in February which called for "urgently stopping industrial discharges" containing eternal pollutants "without waiting for European restrictions", the MoDem deputy Cyrille Isaac-Sibille tabled an amendment which plans to postpone the ban applied to kitchen utensils as of January 1, 2030.

One of the banners displayed on Saturday March 2, 2024 by activists who entered the site of the chemical industry group Arkema in Pierre-Bénite (Rhône) to denounce perfluorinated pollution. © Sylvain Thizy, AFP

A position taken concomitantly with the mobilization of the kitchenware manufacturer Seb, who this week brandished the threat that such a law would pose on employment.

On Wednesday, hundreds of employees supported by their management organized a gathering near the National Assembly to demand the “withdrawal” of the text. “Don’t touch my frying pan,” we could read on signs.

The law would threaten 3,000 jobs at the Seb factories in Rumilly (Haute-Savoie) and Tournus (Saône-et-Loire) which notably manufacture Tefal stoves, and the polytetrafluoroethene used for the coating of the latter would not be dangerous, according to the band.

Questioned by AFP, Nicolas Thierry denounced the "rather crude lobbying" of an industrialist who "disseminates scientifically erroneous information" and who engages in "classic blackmail of employment" while "the future will be written without eternal pollutants" and that alternatives already exist for culinary products.

“Eternal chemicals” © Jonathan Walter, AFP

“If, on such a serious public health subject, when there is a scientific, political, citizen consensus, we do not act, when do we do it?”, he expressed alarm.

According to Jean-Marc Zulesi (Renaissance), president of the Sustainable Development Committee, the position of the Macronist group is "not stabilized". If some want to reject the text, others plead for pushing back the deadline from 2026 to 2030. “An eternity” for Nicolas Thierry.

With AFP

The France 24 summary of the week

invites you to look back at the news that marked the week

I subscribe

Take international news everywhere with you! Download the France 24 application