Europe 1 with AFP 5:49 p.m., April 1, 2024

More than 80% of payments from the European Union's Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) are intended directly or indirectly for livestock farming, undermining the EU's climate objectives, underlines a study in the scientific journal Nature Food, published Monday.

While food systems represent nearly a third of greenhouse gas emissions that contribute to global warming, the CAP is “economically dissuasive for transitions” towards more sustainable practices, according to this study.

“We have shown that the CAP disproportionately supports meat products to the detriment of plant production,” indicates the lead author of the study, Anniek Kortleve, from the Dutch University of Leiden.

>> READ ALSO -

 Agricultural anger: the 27 examine a revision of the CAP, tractors expected in Brussels

Agriculture that emits high levels of greenhouse gases

“It’s a bit of a surprise. It’s a bit more pronounced than what other previously published studies have shown, because of the consideration of aid for animal feed,” she said. explained to AFP.

Direct subsidies to breeders represent half of the aid - which amounted to 57 billion euros in 2013 - thus financing agriculture that emits high greenhouse gases, according to the researchers.

The rest is largely made up of subsidies to support livestock production, particularly food production, according to the study. Aid for cattle breeding thus increases from 71 euro cents per kilo to 1.42 euros, including cattle feed.

“Emissions from the food system are enough to take us beyond 1.5 degrees”

The study focuses on 2013, the last year when all the analyzed data is available, but the aid figures show that "little has changed" in their distribution until 2020, Paul Behrens explained to AFP , co-author of the study.

>> READ ALSO - 

Agricultural crisis: European farmers denounce “a half-response” from the EU

Given the importance of agricultural aid in the EU budget, the authors of the study believe that it undermines the European continent's objectives in terms of mitigation and adaptation to global warming.

On a global scale, “emissions from the food system are enough to take us beyond 1.5 degrees,” said Paul Behrens, referring to the limit on temperature rise set by the Paris climate agreement of 2015 compared to pre-industrial times.

Reinvent the system

“It will be very difficult to respect this objective if we put in place an economic system which encourages the most harmful productions,” added Paul Behrens, associate professor at the University of Leiden.

Reserving tracts of land for livestock and their feed also prevents reforestation and other practices that could allow the return of more plant and animal species and better carbon absorption, he added.

Recognizing the importance of aid for farmers, he called for "reinventing" the system to encourage "environmental services" while adapting to the "much more precarious" conditions linked to global warming.