Oppositions on Meloni's speech: "An ideological manifesto rather than a programmatic speech"

Predictably, the reactions of the

to Giorgia Meloni's programmatic speech have seen alternating the "ordinance" coldness of those who do not intend to vote trust with some lukewarm appreciation on some well-defined points, especially the reference to women who have built the ladder she climbed.

Among the coldest, the

, which would like to lead an opposition to the government (which however appears, at least for now, a distant mirage).

Cold also the

, deployed in the sword defense of citizenship income, whose cancellation - even if only briefly - agitates the general staff of Conte & co.

The only ones to have shown less hostility to the words of the Prime Minister, the deputies of the so-called

(finished fourth in the elections), which represent the smallest opposition group.

While the statements of the groups in Montecitorio alternate at a rapid pace before the vote on confidence, the reaction of the members of each parliamentary group explains what the positions of the opposition are with respect to the executive.

The Democratic Party and the 5 Star Movement have already promised an opposition without discounts.

Action and Italia Viva speak of "rhetoric" without any concrete proposal, but do not exclude their collaboration should there be shared proposals in the future.

Handle

Serracchiani, Letta and Schlein in the Chamber

The comments of the Democratic Party

The secretary of the Democratic Party,

, listens to the intervention of the Prime Minister from his seat, in silence.

The dem, in any case, are in fibrillation for what they call "an ideological manifesto" rather than a government program.

And they assure that, if there were the feared backsliding on rights, their "opposition would be very firm", explains the parent company of the dem,

, adding that "a text indicating how, with what priorities, resources would have been more productive and effective. and interventions this government aims to lead the country out of a dramatic crisis.

Tools - comments Serracchiani - that are only useful for those who have more and push the most exposed, the most fragile, to the back of the row ”.

The former minister of labor,

, intercepted in the Transatlantic by reporters, points out the absence in Meloni's speech of "any reference to policies for work, precariousness, income", adding that "the only thing that Meloni has put in place is his personal history, having left out concrete answers on the issues that matter ”.

What is worrying, however, is above all the part that concerns the tax authorities with that reference to the flat tax and fiscal peace.

"Giorgia Meloni has proposed a more unjust Italy: amnesty to the clever, a wink to the tax evaders, less taxes to the rich", emphasizes

.

Handle

The benches of the Democratic Party in the House

And while the vice president of the Chamber

says she is positively impressed by the reference to women made by the premier, the former president of Montecitorio

defines the statements of the prime minister "very controversial, vague on economic and labor issues, self-referential and based on of nationalist rhetoric ”, adding that“ the right has confirmed that it does not have a migration policy ”.

Laura Boldrini also made it clear that she is happy with the fact that the leader of the Brothers of Italy has removed from her vocabulary the use of the concept of "naval blockade, which in international law is equivalent to an act of war".

She then concludes: “The Prime Minister invoked the motto

.

I want to remind you that in democracy, those who govern have always passed the scrutiny of the opposition.

So rest assured: we will disturb ”.

Handle

Giorgia Meloni and Nicola Fratoianni in the Chamber

The 5 Star Movement replies ironically to Meloni: “Thank goodness they were ready”,

writes on social media , recalling the slogan used by Meloni in the electoral campaign.

"The theme is the political discontinuity from Mario Draghi" adds

, group leader in the Chamber: "It is a species that no mention has been made of the government thanks to which there are 240 billion PNRRs in Italy today," says Ricciardi.

The opposition on the left of the Democratic Party is even harder.

“It seems to me an intervention that marks continuity with the choice of the presidents of the chambers, with the change of the names of the ministries.

All calibrated on the identity and nature of an ideological manifesto of the Italian and European right ": to underline it, the leader of the Italian Left,

.

"Almost nothing was said about the economy, there was only a succession of words and symbols that recall the ideological manifesto of the right: merit, migrants, taxes, up to the even impressive call to the condemnation of militant anti-fascism that seems to cancel the anti-fascist resistance despite the condemnation of the racial laws, which we appreciate ”notes Fratoianni.

And to those who point out that Meloni has declared that she has never liked fascism, the leader of SI replies: “It makes you smile.

Those who rise to institutional positions in this country also suffer from amnesia with respect to their own history.

Even in terms of language,

seems to me the classic system of that right, however we will see… ”.

(Rainews)

Carlo Calenda

Carlo Calenda

, who also announced his willingness to discuss the measures that Action will deem acceptable, describes the speech of the Prime Minister as “an endless shopping list seasoned with tons of rhetoric, but no trace on how to do things.

No choice or idea of ​​country.

It is all a

.

It seemed like an intervention by Conte, other than a sovereign revolution.

A deadly bore ”adds Calenda, for which however Meloni's attack on citizenship income and Italy's international positioning are points in favor.

"Great satisfaction for the intention of the Brothers of Italy to set up a commission of inquiry to investigate the management of the pandemic and in particular to shed light on who has possibly profited from the acquisitions linked to Covid" is known from sources of Italia Viva .

But the Renzians also welcome the strong confirmation, arrived from Meloni, on the Atlanticist position of the country.

For

, group leader Iv in the Senate, the "vagueness on economic issues" represents what is most obscure in Meloni's speech.

MP Iv is more caustic,

: "I hope President Meloni has realized that he is no longer in the opposition," says the deputy close to Matteo Renzi, adding that the premier's speech is all aimed at getting "some standing ovations".

Elisabetta A. Villa / Getty Images

Lucio Villari (archive photo)

The only, interesting discordant voice, that of an authoritative exponent of Italian historiography, of ancient progressive tradition: “As a historian and as a man interested in left-wing politics, I am very satisfied with this discourse.

It was the speech of a high-level politician who grasped the essential problems of the country, without resorting to ideological formulas, rather distancing herself from fascism ”, commented the historian

.

And he adds: "I appreciated the reference to the fight against the mafia, the memory of women who contributed to the development of democracy and the commitments on economic and social issues".