On the 1st, I pointed out that the key to 'Kim Ki-hyun's suspicions about Ha Myung-su is a source of intelligence'. Depending on who provided information to Cheong Wa Dae, specifically former former Cheong Wa Dae civil affairs secretary, he pointed out whether the Blue House was involved in elections using an investigative agency, or whether the report was simply a spy without an intention to intervene. In particular, four sources of intelligence are given, and all but the first case may be subject to serious illegal charges. The Blue House also demanded that the 'source of intelligence' be promptly identified.
The number of four cases I presented at the time is as follows.
1) Stakeholders (parts of apartment construction works, etc.) appearing in the intelligence report directly to former secretary Baek Won-woo
2) The Democratic candidate who was a rival of the Democratic Party or former Kim Ki-hyun, informed Baek former secretary.
3) The police or other intelligence / agency staff contacted the person involved in the case and produced information and reported it to the former secretary.
4) The Blue House employee under former secretary Baek Won-woo produced an information and reported it to the former secretary.
▶ [Report File] Who provided information to Baek Won Woo? : Criteria for Judgment of Suspicion of Ha Myung In (2019.12.01)
Three days later, the Blue House gave a briefing to reveal the source of intelligence. The Cheong Wa Dae, a deputy mayor of Ulsan Mayor Song Cheol-ho, a Democratic Party, was running for the mayor of Ulsan Mayor of the Democratic Party in October 2017. It was reported. Since then, the Moon administration has not added the contents and organized it in a report form and reported it to the Blue House Civil Affairs Secretary at the time, Won-Woo Baek, a Blue House official. (※ The Blue House did not disclose the real name or position of Deputy Mayor Song Byung-gi, explaining the process, but as a result of the reporters' report, the reporter indicated that Blue House was Deputy Mayor Song Byung-gi.) Cheong Wa Dae explained that he passed it to Park Hyung-cheol, an anti-corruption secretary who worked with him in the Civil Affairs Office, and secretary Park Hyung-cheol sent a spy to the police office.
The Blue House's explanation itself seems to fall into scenario 2, which I pointed out when illegal matters had to be raised in the file on the last day. In October 2017, when the report was made, Deputy Mayor Song Byeong-gi, a reporter, was assisting Mayor Song Cheol-ho, who was preparing to run for the Democratic Party. Is reported in the " I explained in my report that I could be accused of "investigating the election". However, the Blue House could not be called 'election intervention' because the Blue House received the report from Deputy Mayor Song Cheol-ho, who was close to Democratic Party Mayor Song Cheol-ho. Doing.
After all, the crux of the case is whether the Blue House's intention to intervene. To put it a little further, whether the Blue House had informed Kim Ki-hyun, former Ulsan Mayor, a member of the Liberal Korean Party, and then consigned to the police had the 'intention of intervening in elections'. The key point is whether there was no intention of election intervention as the Blue House asserted, or was it intended as some argue.
To judge this, we need to review the following three issues.
(※ The reason why the alleged abuse or violation of election law can be applied when the intention of election election is proved was explained in detail in the report file released last day.)
Whether the Cheong Wa Dae was preparing to run for Democratic Party candidates, whether the receptionist of the opposition party Kim Ki-hyun, who received opposition from Ulsan Mayor at the time of opposition party, was 'information receptionist' or 'information production' to judge whether the Blue House's intention to engage in elections was judged. Can be an important criterion. If it were not "simply reporting" but "producing intelligence," there could be suspicion that the Blue House had illegally inspected the elected local government head for opposition.
(※ This does not mean that it is not a problem in the case of a simple report. There is something else to consider. I will explain it when reviewing issue 2.)
The Blue House claims that the process of obtaining intelligence on former opposition mayor Kim Ki-hyun was just a report. In October 2017, Deputy Mayor Song Byung-ki, an aide of Mayor Song Cheol-ho, who was preparing to run for Democratic Party at the time, first reported the Kim's misconduct suspicion through the smartphone SNS to the administrative officer of the Blue House's Civil Affairs Office. Has re-edited the report into a report format, claiming that it was reported to his superiors without any additional content. Cheong Wa Dae explained that the information reported by Deputy Mayor Song passed through Cheong Wa Dae's Civil Affairs Office, but without any corrections to the police. It wasn't an active spy production.
But some question the Blue House clarification. In summary, Democratic Party lawmaker Hong Ik-pyo (*) argued that Cheong Wa Dae directly saw the documents sent to the police as they did not correct the reports of Deputy Mayor Song Byung-ki. It is said to contain suspicion of 3 nipples. Another investigative official said, "The information, form, and content of intelligence is very professional." Given the four pages and the professional contents, there is a suspicion that a criminal intelligence production specialist, such as a Blue House civilian senior staff, may have intervened in the process.
Also, whether Deputy Mayor Song Byeong-gi provided intelligence first, or whether the Blue House asked for information first, could be an important criterion when deciding whether to file a simple report or produce an active intelligence. In response, the Blue House argued that Deputy Mayor Song Byeong-gi first provided information. But Deputy Mayor Song is different. YTN spoke with Vice Mayor Song Byung-gi on the 5th, saying, "There are people who occasionally collect trends. The government. Kim ○○ Mr. Kim keeps appearing in the media regarding complaints and accusations. I just broadcast the voice. At the same time, YTN said, "The deputy mayor of Song had been asked by the Blue House first and explained." The Dong-A Ilbo also spoke with the Mayor of Song in an article on the 5th of last month, saying, “Is there any unusual trend in Ulsan area in September and October 2017? I don't remember whether it was a KakaoTalk or a letter. ”
In summary, to determine whether the Blue House intends to intervene in elections, it is first necessary to judge whether it is a (simple) report or a production of (active) intelligence. The Blue House received the report and delivered it to the police without any corrections, claiming it was a (simple) receipt and not (active) intelligence production. However, there are doubts about the amount of intelligence and the professional content of the Blue House, which actively involved in the production of intelligence. There is a controversy between the deputy mayor and the Blue House claim regarding whether it is 'Song Byung Gi provided first or the Blue House requested first' as another criterion to determine whether it is a (simple) report or a (active) intelligence production. . We need to see what evidence will be supported by media coverage or prosecution investigations.
However, the Blue House's process of securing information regarding Kim Ki-hyun's former Ulsan market, as claimed by the Blue House, was not just an active production of Blue House's intelligence, but a simple report reception, but the Blue House's intention to intervene in elections did not disappear immediately. Even if it was a simple report, the question remains as to what purpose and criteria the report was submitted to.
Kim Dae-hyun, former vice chairman of the Blue House Civil affairs secretary at the time when he received reports from the former Ulsan Mayor, said on November 28, “In the Blue House civil affairs room, there are a lot of reports received through various information and mail. Focused ". "There is so much information that I can't remember about the reports that I have forwarded the Ulsan Mayor's report to the anti-corruption secretary." Common sense suggests that a tremendous amount of information will be sent to the Blue House Civil Service.
By the way, the Blue House Civil Affairs Senior Office does not hand over all of this tremendous amount of information to investigative agencies. Even if the Blue House has inspected the matters directly or complained to each administrative department, there are a lot of misbehavior reports or intelligence that do not belong to them, and it will not be appropriate or physically possible to hand them all over to the investigative agencies. For this reason, the Blue House selects from among a number of intelligences which are subject to specific intentions and criteria. Cheong Wa Dae's acting on the intelligence agency is a discretionary act involving Blue House's intentions and standards.
That is why the Blue House decided to determine the purpose of the election of the Blue House to determine the purpose and standards of the 'discretionary act' in which the opposition party Kim Ki-hyun, former Ulsan Mayor, was involved with the National Police Agency. It is an important criterion. If the Blue House proved that, among the many information, the reason for selecting the intelligence agency for former mayor Kim Ki-hyun, the chief of the opposition, was to `` investigate the police to investigate the opposition candidate ahead of the election. '' The Blue House could be judged to have an intention to intervene. On the other hand, if Cheong Wa Dae's decision to lead intelligence to former mayor Kim Ki-hyun is based on a separate standard that has nothing to do with Kim's involvement in the opposition, he suspects normal and administrative measures without the intention to elect the election. Could be evaluated as having no basis.
However, another point to be considered was whether the Blue House knew that the reporter at the time of October 2017, Song Byeong-gi, the deputy mayor of Ulsan City, was an aide to the mayor of Ulsan, which was preparing for a Democratic candidate. If Cheong Wa Dae was aware that Whistleblower Song Cheol-ho was close to Ulsan Mayor Song Cheol-ho, who was competing with Kim Ki-hyun, who was opposition party Kim Ki-hyun, even if the Cheong Wa Dae wrote the report to the investigation agency without any correction, There is no doubt that it was intended. If the Blue House, which must maintain political neutrality in the elections, has handed over to the investigating agency a report from an aide of a clear stakeholder involved in the election and is likely to run as a candidate for the ruling party, the intelligence agency has chosen the information to be a target for the espionage. It is because the suspicion is inevitable. Indeed, the Blue House's deputy mayor, Song Byeong-gi, was aware of the fact that he was an aide of Mayor Song Cheol-ho, who was preparing to run for the Democratic Party. That's what it should be.
In addition, Park Hyung-cheol's prosecution secretary's statement on the information delivery process is also worth noting in relation to the Blue House's intention of espionage. Park Hyung-Cheol reportedly stated in the prosecution's investigation that the "Park Won-woo Minjeong secretary handed the document directly to me, and the document contained only intelligence related to the former Ulsan Mayor Kim Ki-hyun." (※ Former secretary Baek Won-woo revealed that he does not remember.) If Park's statement is true, this is the situation where Cheong Wa Dae or former secretary Baek Won-woo treated 'Information on Kim Ki-hyun's Ulsan Market' very specially. Can be interpreted as It is very rare for the Blue House secretary, a first-class official, to hand out a specific intelligence to another secretary in a civilian high-ranking room where a lot of information is concentrated and entangled. If Park's statement is true, the 'special reason' of special treatment of former Kim Ki-hyun and former secretary Baek Won-woo should also be identified.
The Blue House claims that the Blue House is related to Kim Ki-hyun's former information on the Mayor of Ulsan. However, regarding 'Kim Ki-hyun's information on Ulsan Mayor', there is still a point to check whether there was no other activities of the Blue House or the government agencies other than 'Contact Song Byeong-ki-Blue House Administrator' in October 2017.
In response, Cheong Wa Dae visited Ulsan about the Whale Meat Incident in January 2018. There is no separate Blue House activity involved. On the other side, however, prosecutor Investigator A, who was a former official under Baek Won-woo's former civil affairs secretary, took his own life after receiving a prosecutor's reference to the suspicion of Ha Myung Suh. Is there a reason why you took your life in the process of being investigated for suspicions of investigation? ' Cheong Wa Dae officials and ruling party lawmakers insist that the death of the deceased person, apparently involved only in the whale meat case, means the prosecution has made a coercive investigation or a separate case.
Among the evidences that have appeared in the press so far are the mobile phones left by the dead A investigator. There is a possibility that there is a lot of evidence that the Blue House or a government agency has been engaged in activities related to Kim Ki-hyun's former Ulsan Mayor, and whether the death of the deceased is related to a prosecution case or other pressure. However, investigator A's cell phone is an iPhone X, so it is known that the prosecution service has not been able to analyze the contents yet. However, if you use the Israeli equipment installed in the United States, you can unlock it, so the prosecution will be able to analyze the contents over time.
There are some doubts about the activities of Cheong Wa Dae or other government agencies in relation to Kim Ki-hyun's intelligence, besides the “Consul Song-Ki-Jung administration”. However, if Cheong Wa Dae or other government agencies were informed by former opposition leader Kim Ki-hyun about former Ulsan mayor, the Blue House's intention to intervene in elections or suspicion of illegal civilian inspections, regardless of the conclusions of issue 1 and issue 2, May swell. The suspicion will depend on what evidence or statement comes through media coverage or prosecution investigations.
■ Why can't you give up?
Again, the key to the suspicion of Ha Myung Su is whether or not the Blue House intends to intervene in elections. If after the prosecutors' investigation, there is not enough evidence to show the Blue House's intention to engage in elections, the case could end with a huge happening that was a heavy social energy drain. But if evidence reveals the Blue House's intention to intervene in elections, it could be characterized as a critical event in which the Blue House tried to intervene in elections. Unfortunately, the prosecution's investigation has once again taken too much social wage.
After the prosecution's investigation, I sincerely hope that both conclusions will be presented on the above three issues and that the concrete evidence supporting them will be revealed. If even the prosecution's investigation reveals no clear facts in the case of a "social stake," the conflict between those who are now divided into two camps and in deep opposition will no longer be tolerable. Of course, it is true that even after a clear fact is revealed, it tends to disapprove until the end if it is a disadvantage for the camp to which it belongs. Even so, you cannot give up on revealing the truth and revealing the truth. Whatever the truth and what the truth is, a society that no longer matters can't be kept normal.
[Reporting file] The main point of suspicion of Ha Myung's investigation is 'intention to intervene in elections', three issues to consider
2019-12-08T07:40:40.508Z
On the 1st, I pointed out that the key to 'Kim Ki-hyun's suspicions about Ha Myung-su is a source of intelligence'. Depending on who provided information to Cheong Wa Dae, specifically former former Cheong Wa Dae civil affairs secretary, he pointed out whether the Blue House was involved in elections using an investigative agency, or whether the report was simply a spy without an intention to intervene.
Source: sbskr