After her story topped social media platforms in Egypt, and was reported by websites and newspapers, and won praise and thanks from the National Council for Women, local media questioned the "heroism" of the eastern girl, Amani Muhammad, who claimed to have saved a family from drowning.

Since last Saturday, the state of controversy has prevailed in the Egyptian street, after a number of residents of the Minya al-Qamh center in Sharkia Governorate denied the drowning incident, while an eyewitness claimed to the "Al-Asima" website that Amani offered her 100,000 pounds in exchange for confirming her story of saving two women and 4 children from drowning in a canal in Sharkia. .

According to the "Cairo 24" newspaper, medical sources in Zagazig University Hospitals confirmed that the reception and emergency department in the hospital did not receive or receive reports or people suffering from post-drowning symptoms during last Saturday, and the security services of the Eastern Security Directorate did not receive any reports about the incident. .

For its part, the Sharkia Governorate (the location of the incident) canceled a ceremony honoring the girl, which she had decided to organize after communicating with hospitals affiliated with the Ministry of Health and the university. In addition, the same place did not witness any accidents during this time.

The President of the National Council for Women, Dr. Maya Morsi, deleted a post she posted last Saturday on her Facebook site, in which she thanked Amani and celebrated her, saying, “The daughter of Minya al-Qamh, the hero of the Eastern Province, the hero of the Republic, the courageous Egyptian girl.. Sergeant Amani did not think for a moment about saving the family of two women and 4 Children from drowning, after the car they were traveling in overturned in the waters of a canal passing through the Abu Tabl area in Minya al-Qamh.

Amani Muhammad narrated the details of the story to the Egyptian newspaper, Al-Shorouk, saying, “Several days ago, I was surprised by the overturning of my angel’s car, with two women and 4 children on board, in the waters of the canal near the Abu Drum Bridge in the Minya Al-Qamh Center district. Immediately, I took a piece of iron and jumped into the water and broke glass.” the car to get the passengers out of the car before they drowned.”

The young woman added to the "Cairo 24" website, "The canal is deep, and there was a vortex in the water. At that time, I knew of my death. My concern was to save people. Praise be to God, our Lord, saved us all, and after that I felt great joy."

And in the event that the invalidity of Amani Muhammad’s story is proven, it is likely that she will be subject to the text of Articles 305 and 302, and their penalty of imprisonment for a period of up to 3 years, for spreading false news, and taking the rule of false communication and unnecessarily disturbing people, according to what was reported by the local newspaper, “Veto”, according to the legal expert. Court of Cassation, Ismail Baraka.