Sent by one of our readers, a publication estimates that several thousand manuscripts have been found in a monastery in Tibet.
They would hide “50,000 years of history”.
Except that the age of the books seems suspect because writing did not exist 50,000 years ago.
Moreover, the real discovery of these manuscripts dates back to 2003. No secret was discovered in these books.
Could we have found traces of part of history thanks to books found in Tibet?
This is confirmed by a publication sent by one of our readers, via our WhatsApp discussion.
“This news seems dubious and is spreading,” he warns.
Indeed, the tweet has been widely shared since its publication on August 4th.
The description reads: "The library found in Tibet contains 84,000 secret manuscripts (books) spanning 50,000 years of human history."
The library found in Tibet contains 84,000 secret manuscripts (books) covering 50,000 years of human history.
Sakia Monastery.
Perhaps the largest library in the world in the distant history of the planet.
He was discovered behind a huge wall.
pic.twitter.com/HcjfUu8uZA
— Steph (@Stephan95105295) August 4, 2022
Access to this content has been blocked to respect your choice of consent
By clicking on "
I ACCEPT
", you accept the deposit of cookies by external services and will thus have access to the content of our partners
I ACCEPT
And to better remunerate 20 Minutes, do not hesitate to accept all cookies, even for one day only, via our "I accept for today" button in the banner below.
More information on the Cookie Management Policy page.
The discovery would be at the monastery of Sakya.
“It may be the largest library in the world in the distant history of the planet,” the publication adds.
However, there is no indication of when this discovery dates back.
Only one detail is revealed: the books would have been discovered behind a huge wall.
Only, here, nothing proves the contents of these books.
FAKE OFF
In southern Tibet, Sakya Monastery is considered one of the main schools of Tibetan Buddhism.
It is particularly famous for its library, which is said to be the largest in the autonomous region.
According to the
Lonely Planet
, the heritage has “about 24,000 texts comprising 8,848 reams of writing”.
But if the library of Sakya Monastery does exist, the discovery of the manuscripts actually seems like a chestnut tree when it comes to historical myths.
Writing not yet discovered
Published a year ago, a video by the YouTuber “Planète Raw” already referred to this intriguing library.
But a first element is modified between the tweet and the video.
The youtubeur speaks of a library kept for nearly 10,000 years, unlike the Twitter account which relies on “50,000 years of human history”.
Moreover, the figure differs systematically between the publications.
On the Reddit forum, Internet users even reduce the duration to "1,000 years of history".
Anyway, it shows the lack of precision of this information.
Questionable information?
Go through WhatsApp
Indeed, how could the manuscripts discovered at the monastery of Sakya date back 50,000 years when writing did not yet exist?
Remember, we had to wait until the end of prehistory to see the appearance of the first writings.
The discovery takes place in the middle of Mesopotamia.
If at the beginning it is mainly about pictograms rather than a real writing, we are at this period much more advanced in the calendar of humanity.
Here is the second error of the publication: the manuscripts cannot go back so far in history, while writing was invented only in 3,400-3,300 BC.
A 20 year old story
In the video of "Raw Planet", we also learn that the discovery of the manuscripts is not recent and would actually date back to 2003. The Chinese press agency Xinhua made mention of this news on November 15 of this same year.
She then explained that the discovery took place during the restoration of the monastery.
The dispatch does explain that the manuscripts were stored in a wall, but adds: "No one knows any further details about them since they have remained untouched for the past hundreds of years."
But what do these mysterious manuscripts contain?
“Scholars of Buddhism believe that the majority of the huge collection may consist primarily of Buddhist scripture and probably also covers a wide variety of fields including literature, history, philosophy, astronomy, mathematics and art”, lists the Xinhua press agency in 2003. However, nothing proves that these manuscripts hide “a secret” which would change the course of History.
Planet
Caution when interpreting these satellite images which compare France between 2021 and 2022
World
France would have violated the Minsk protocol by delivering weapons to Ukraine as revealed by Gabriel Attal?
It's wrong
World
Story
Tibet
fake-off
Buddhism