Happy may be very intelligent, but that doesn't make her a person.

And for good reason: Happy is an elephant, who has lived for 45 years at the Bronx Zoo in New York.

American justice was seized by the association for the defense of animals Nonhuman Rights Project, which demanded the transfer of the pachyderm to a sanctuary.

This Asian elephant is "extraordinarily autonomous and cognitively complex" and should be "recognized as a legal person with the right to freedom", had pleaded the association.

The court's ruling means Happy—a 51-year-old Asian elephant at the Bronx Zoo—is not entitled to the fundamental right of bodily liberty, or freedom from imprisonment https://t.co/VVM01byoL0

— National Geographic (@NatGeo) June 14, 2022


Access to this content has been blocked to respect your choice of consent

By clicking on "

I ACCEPT

", you accept the deposit of cookies by external services and will thus have access to the content of our partners

I ACCEPT

And to better remunerate 20 Minutes, do not hesitate to accept all cookies, even for one day only, via our "I accept for today" button in the banner below.

More information on the Cookie Management Policy page.


Disagreement among judges

The New York Court of Appeals ruled on Tuesday, finding that elephants are indeed "intelligent beings who deserve adequate care and compassion".

But according to the judges, the right to liberty cannot apply to "a non-human animal, which is not a 'person' subject to unlawful detention".

For the head of the Court of Appeal, Janet DiFiore, proving Happy would upset all “interactions between humans and animals” in terms of property, agribusiness or medical research.

Two of the seven judges, however, dissociated themselves from this decision, considering that Happy should have been granted a right to liberty "not only because she is a wild animal who is not supposed to be in cages and on display, but also because giving rights to others defines our society”.

Janet DiFiore underlined the “enormous interest” that this file aroused among the public.

“It speaks to the complicated and evolving relationship between humans and animals,” she wrote, hoping the debate continues in legislatures rather than in court.

The association has already introduced similar remedies for other elephants and chimpanzees in the United States.

Planet

Discovered in the Galapagos, this turtle belongs to a species that has disappeared for 100 years

Planet

Mexico: This reserve collects wild animals and exotic animals illegally detained

  • elephant

  • New York

  • Zoo

  • Freedom

  • Human rights

  • Justice

  • Animals

  • World