"Li Ziqi" was written into the Chinese test paper and caused controversy
The person who made the question responded that "it is a celebrity but worth learning." What does the industry think?
Recently, a final language exam paper for the sixth grade of elementary school in Ningbo, Zhejiang, became popular on the Internet. The reason for the fire was a reading comprehension question, which provided three paragraphs of materials such as Yuan Longping and Li Ziqi. "Fengyun characters" write a recommendation form. After the test paper was exposed on the Internet, it unexpectedly caused a variety of controversies among netizens. Subsequently, the teacher who responded to the school test paper responded that the reason for choosing Li Ziqi was because the major media were competing to report their positives. The content commends Li Ziqi for his contribution to traditional culture and the spirit of doing things seriously. Although such a character is an Internet celebrity, it is indeed worth learning.
Yangzi Evening News/Ziniu News reporter Huang Yanwen
Netizens argue
"Should internet celebrities appear on the more influential test papers, will it bring children's values?" The netizen's suspicions soon sparked controversy. The reporter also saw the final volume on the Internet, and found that this question is not a composition question, but part of the reading material in the non-continuous text reading comprehension question. The title provides three sections of materials, including Yuan Longping, Li Ziqi and Lei Haiwei (the takeaway brother who won the "Chinese Poetry Conference" champion). In addition to examining the ability to generalize the reading materials, the children were also asked to choose one of the three characters to be recommended as a "character in mind" and give reasons.
There are mixed comments on this online. Some people think that Li Ziqi and Yuan Longping are not in the same field, and the two cannot be compared. "Li Ziqi and Yuan Longping, no matter in the field or influence, there is no comparability. The topic is not suitable for primary school students." "Education is treated equally for every child, of course children can have personalized learning, children know that Internet celebrity is considered personalized learning. Well, it’s not a bad thing, but taking the celebrity test on the unified exam is to let the children know about the celebrity, and it’s wrong.” “You can give out questions about the celebrity and comment on the celebrity, but you can’t be specific about a Internet celebrity."
Some netizens believe that the education of children should be personalized learning, and Chinese is an all-encompassing subject. It is not a bad thing to let children know about Internet celebrity knowledge in advance.
Responder
Facing the debate on the Internet, Yang Liu, the teacher of the proposition group of the Haishu District Primary School Graduation Exam, responded: "We took into account the character Li Ziqi when we asked the question, and all major media have made positive reports. The spirit of contribution and conscientiousness is really worth learning."
Teacher Yang Liu also explained in detail the reason for choosing Li Ziqi. First of all, as a reading comprehension question in Chinese, the proposition group gives three language materials in discontinuous text reading. It mainly examines the students' reading comprehension ability, which includes information extraction, summary information, judgment information, and interpretation information. Ability and ability to think. Therefore, it is not necessary for students to swipe their mobile phones to understand that Li Ziqi, a talented person, can do a question, and the problem can be solved by the materials given in the test paper. Secondly, from the perspective of Yuan Longping, Li Ziqi, and Lei Hai's choice of the three characters, the value that the proposition group wants to convey is that no matter what industry they are engaged in, in the process of pursuing their dreams, they need to pay hard and continuous Work hard. Parents are more concerned about the problem of online celebrities entering the test paper. The proposition group's consideration at the time was that Li Ziqi was commented on by CCTV and studied in the powerful country and the People’s Daily. It also reflects the diversity of contemporary culture and its own story. Also more inspirational.
Education experts suggest
Zhao Changzhu, a Chinese language leader in Xuanwu District, Nanjing, and a Chinese teacher at Changjiang Road Primary School, has been engaged in elementary school Chinese language education for many years. He believes that Chinese language learning is originally a subject that recognizes the world through literary works, literary works, and different people. The textbooks still read from outside the class, they will meet different characters, this is a very normal phenomenon, then some of this character may define it as a network character, or a "net red" , But in fact, it does have some places worthy of everyone’s praise, including the promotion of traditional culture, etc. It is not a negative character, so Mr. Zhao Changzhu believes that there is no need to specifically question such a character. . In addition, Teacher Zhao also mentioned that students may focus more on understanding the text when doing the question. After finishing this question, they rarely think too much about the image of Li Ziqi, but the parents May be a little too much.
Mr. Zhang Wenjia, deputy headmaster of the 12th Middle School of Nanjing City and leader of the Chinese subject in Gulou District, thinks that this reading question is a good one. "We need to think about a question. What can children get in the study of Chinese? What kind of literacy can they improve?" Teacher Zhang Wenjia said that from this topic alone, the teacher's intention is very clear, and students can be investigated. Basic language skills and positive value guidance. Teacher Zhang Wenjia also discussed her views from two aspects: cultural understanding and aesthetic appreciation. "Cultural understanding includes the inheritance of local culture, the understanding of international culture, the return of life culture and the care of natural culture. The phenomenon of Li Ziqi from From a cultural point of view, it is also very valuable. Her story has been embedded in the genes of traditional Chinese culture, as well as a longing for a beautiful and peaceful life, as well as an understanding of natural culture, and indeed as a window for the world to understand China Why not be sure? Let’s talk about aesthetic appreciation, including feeling beauty, appreciating beauty, creating beauty, and pursuing beauty’s personality. Li Ziqi’s videos all show a kind of beauty, and behind this visible beauty, there is still a look Unattainable beauty. Li Ziqi's dark face, powerful forearm, and rough hands are beautiful? These can guide students to think.
In addition, Teacher Zhang Wenjia thinks that “Internet celebrity” is just a neutral word and can’t stand for something. “Dr. Zhong Nanshan, is Dr. Zhang Wenhong an Internet celebrity? Is news spokesman Geng Shuang considered an Internet celebrity? It's also a red circle. Is there an inspirational li Jiaqi who is a celebrity?" Zhang Wenjia sincerely hopes that there will be more such celebrities.
Of course, Teacher Zhang Wenjia said that if you want to talk about the flaws of this question, there are also some concerns about the number of followers of the blog. "The number of fans does not have much contact with the topic itself and can be removed."